On Sun, 20 Jan 2008 12:45:21 -0800, El Castor <No_One@Here.Com> wrote: On Sun, 20 Jan 2008 13:57:04 -0600, "Jean Paul" <jobbahut@hotmail.com> wrote: "Justine" <wherethereistruth@freedom.net> wrote in message news:pq87p31l8ej38ukbc1o263lo71kock97ji@4ax.com... What a magnificent, stunning movie! It is amazingly powerful in it's emotional evocation and a beautiful
On Jan 14, 1:23 pm, susan <frogandtoa...@msn.com> wrote: On Jan 14, 9:07 am, "Robert Neugarten" <r.neugar...@planet.nl> wrote: Also, why atonement? The writer ruined the lives of several people and her atonement was to publicly confess it, fifty years later? There is no atonement. Atonement specifically means being forgiven by God, and this is hardly a story
On Jan 14, 9:07 am, "Robert Neugarten" <r.neugar...@planet.nl> wrote: Also, why atonement? The writer ruined the lives of several people and her atonement was to publicly confess it, fifty years later? There is no atonement. Atonement specifically means being forgiven by God, and this is hardly a story in which He plays a crucial part. hopefully someone will correct me
I am wondering something about a certain difference between the book and the movie, both entitled "Atonement". It concerns the sequence of the events as depicted in the book and then in the movie. My question concerns the scene when Cecilia jumps into the fountain to retrieve the broken parts of the vase. I seem to recall that in the book that scene was shown first. After that, I recall that
On May 22, 1:15 pm, "Robert Neugarten" <r.neugar...@planet.nl> wrote: "pjmcder" <sca...@hotmail.com> schreef in berichtnews:b99e0c3a-1455-4de6-8d5b-37b118436f8e@m3g2000hsc.googlegroups.com... On May 22, 11:43 am, "Bill" <billnh2...@yahoo.com> wrote: My fave movies of the year were Zodiac, Atonement, I'm Not There, In the Valley of Elah and Gone Baby Gone, not necessarily
