Player of the year thoughts
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
uk.sport.football.clubs.celtic only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

uk.sport.football.clubs.celtic Profile…
 Up
Player of the year thoughts         


Author: Stevio
Date: Apr 10, 2008 06:18

Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.

Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players have all
cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that got the most votes,
so the winner has already been decided? When did the players actually cast
their vote for this? I think they always decide these things too soon when
the season still has a bit to go.

Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament before
the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the real player of
the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the award and then had a
poor final.

Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at United?
If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his half season at
Rangers. McGeady - excellent at times but has he been consistent enough? Is
it fair to expect wingers to be consistent? It's a lot harder for skilful
players to be consistent than for a defender. Cueller - good season but am I
alone in thinking he is being talked up too much? He has been caught out at
times. McDonald - he's scored the goals but seems to have gone off the boil
a bit lately.
Show full article (1.34Kb)
11 Comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: Jonbhoy
Date: Apr 10, 2008 08:49

"Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>
> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players have
> all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that got the most
> votes, so the winner has already been decided? When did the players
> actually cast their vote for this? I think they always decide these things
> too soon when the season still has a bit to go.
>
> Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament
> before the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the real
> player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the award and
> then had a poor final.
>
> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at United?
> If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his half season at
> Rangers. McGeady - excellent at times but has he been consistent enough?
> Is it fair to expect wingers to be consistent? It's a lot harder for
> skilful players to be consistent than for a defender. Cueller - good ...
Show full article (1.80Kb)
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: ZB
Date: Apr 10, 2008 11:16

"Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>
> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players have
> all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that got the most
> votes, so the winner has already been decided? When did the players
> actually cast their vote for this? I think they always decide these things
> too soon when the season still has a bit to go.
>
> Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament
> before the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the real
> player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the award and
> then had a poor final.
>
> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at United?
> If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his half season at
> Rangers. McGeady - excellent at times but has he been consistent enough?
> Is it fair to expect wingers to be consistent? It's a lot harder for
> skilful players to be consistent than for a defender. Cueller - good ...
Show full article (1.66Kb)
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: Moody Marco
Date: Apr 10, 2008 14:08

ZB wrote:
> "Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
> news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
>> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>>
>> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players
>> have all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that
>> got the most votes, so the winner has already been decided? When did
>> the players actually cast their vote for this? I think they always
>> decide these things too soon when the season still has a bit to go.
>>
>> Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament
>> before the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the
>> real player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the
>> award and then had a poor final.
>>
>> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at
>> United? If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his
>> half season at Rangers. McGeady - excellent at times but has he been
>> consistent enough? Is it fair to expect wingers to be consistent? ...
Show full article (1.76Kb)
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: ZB
Date: Apr 10, 2008 14:29

"Moody Marco" zoom.co.uk> wrote in message
news:oaydnWyqdeF8HGPanZ2dnUVZ8gOdnZ2d@giganews.com...
> ZB wrote:
>> "Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
>> news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
>>> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>>>
>>> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players
>>> have all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that
>>> got the most votes, so the winner has already been decided? When did
>>> the players actually cast their vote for this? I think they always
>>> decide these things too soon when the season still has a bit to go.
>>>
>>> Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament
>>> before the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the
>>> real player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the
>>> award and then had a poor final.
>>>
>>> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at
>>> United? If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his ...
Show full article (1.98Kb)
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: Moody Marco
Date: Apr 11, 2008 00:35

ZB wrote:
> "Moody Marco" zoom.co.uk> wrote in message
> news:oaydnWyqdeF8HGPanZ2dnUVZ8gOdnZ2d@giganews.com...
>> ZB wrote:
>>> "Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
>>> news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
>>>> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>>>>
>>>> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players
>>>> have all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that
>>>> got the most votes, so the winner has already been decided? When
>>>> did the players actually cast their vote for this? I think they
>>>> always decide these things too soon when the season still has a
>>>> bit to go. Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the
>>>> tournament before the final then made a mistake in the final when
>>>> Ronaldo (the real player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98
>>>> Ronaldo won the award and then had a poor final.
>>>>
>>>> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at
>>>> United? If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his ...
Show full article (2.01Kb)
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: dü the hüsker
Date: Apr 11, 2008 01:03

"Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>
> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players have
> all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that got the most
> votes, so the winner has already been decided? When did the players
> actually cast their vote for this? I think they always decide these things
> too soon when the season still has a bit to go.
>
> Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament
> before the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the real
> player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the award and
> then had a poor final.
>
> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at United?
> If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his half season at
> Rangers. McGeady - excellent at times but has he been consistent enough?
> Is it fair to expect wingers to be consistent? It's a lot harder for
> skilful players to be consistent than for a defender. Cueller - good ...
Show full article (1.80Kb)
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: Stevio
Date: Apr 11, 2008 04:52

"d
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: dü the hüsker
Date: Apr 11, 2008 05:07

"Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
news:MhILj.39305$h65.37187@newsfe2-gui.ntli.net...
> "d
no comments
Re: Player of the year thoughts         


Author: The Sheriff
Date: Apr 11, 2008 12:03

"Stevio" freeuk.com> wrote in message
news:nsoLj.35414$4f4.12628@newsfe6-win.ntli.net...
> Robson, McGeady, Cueller and McDonald.
>
> Who do you think should win it? Am I correct in saying the players have
> all cast their votes already and these are the 4 people that got the most
> votes, so the winner has already been decided? When did the players
> actually cast their vote for this? I think they always decide these things
> too soon when the season still has a bit to go.
>
> Remember the World Cup in 2002 when Kahn won player of the tournament
> before the final then made a mistake in the final when Ronaldo (the real
> player of the tournament) scored twice. In 98 Ronaldo won the award and
> then had a poor final.
>
> Back to Scotland - Robson surely won't win it for half a season at United?
> If that is the case then Hutton should have won it for his half season at
> Rangers. McGeady - excellent at times but has he been consistent enough?
> Is it fair to expect wingers to be consistent? It's a lot harder for
> skilful players to be consistent than for a defender. Cueller - good ...
Show full article (1.59Kb)
no comments
1 2