Re: Some of Zhang Yimou's movies were banned in China and also 2-year ban on filmmaking from 1994...
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
soc.culture.hongkong only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: Some of Zhang Yimou's movies were banned in China and also 2-year ban on filmmaking from 1994...         

Group: soc.culture.hongkong · Group Profile
Author: enterprise
Date: Aug 13, 2008 14:02

I thought I recognize the style. Why did you change your ID,
abianchen?
Simple question.

On Aug 13, 7:59 pm, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
> Ha, as always, you could not refute... now you have to curse. Poor
> thing! Are all mainland Chinese like you??? I hope NOT!
>
> BTW, Jou Dou, Raise the Red Lantern etc Zhang Yimou's early classic
> films were banned in China, I believe the ban is still in effect!!!
>
> Hey people said that house master in "Raise the Red Lantern" portrayed
> CCP and his concubines portrayed Chinese people. What a smart idea!!!
> If you have not seen the movie, it's a classic!!! You should see it to
> understand how talented Zhang Yimou is!!! Too bad, Zhang's recent
> movies are garbage, CCP killed his talent!
>
> On Aug 13, 1:44 pm, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>> On Aug 13, 10:33 am, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>> Because you can't read, understand and think...
>
>>> Like I said, Zhang Yimou has been CCP's puppy last few years and did
>>> not want to offend CCP so he has been making some silly movies last
>>> several years, eg, Hero, Curse of the Golden Flower.. so why should
>>> CCP ban their puppy's movies in China???
>
>>> But some of Zhang Yimou's movies were banned in China in the 90s and
>>> he even got a 2-year ban on filmmaking from 1994.
>
>> Obviously you think it's fun playing the court jester and showing
>> everyone how stupid you are.
>> Are you really so eager to show how stupid a person from Taiwan really
>> can be? You are doing it.
>
>>> On Aug 13, 1:15 pm, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>>>> On Aug 13, 12:45 pm, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>>>> Repost...
>
>>>>> Apparently you don't read all my replies but just whining there.
>
>>>>> Here's what I wrote:
>
>>>>> "Now, just like you, Zhang Yimou has behaved like a puppy to CCP.
>>>>> That's what your CCP wants you to be, a little puppy can say "Yes
>>>>> sir,
>>>>> my beloved CCP".
>
>>>>> “That's why Zhang has been making some silly movies like "Hero"...
>>>>> What a waste! “
>
>>>>> Don't you see "Now" in the above sentence, I provided you CURRENT
>>>>> status of Zhang Yimou, a puppy to CCP, making silly movies like
>>>>> "Hero"
>>>>> etc so he will not offend CCP. But you simply do not read.
>
>>>> I just cannot accept a person can be so stupid as you are. I really
>>>> can't!
>
>>>> I asked, "In which parts of China are his (Zhang Yimou's) work
>>>> banned?".
>>>> "In which parts of China" means "where", where in China? Have you
>>>> written one single location? NO.
>
>>>> You wrote, ""Now, just like you, Zhang Yimou has behaved like a puppy
>>>> to CCP.
>>>> That's what your CCP wants you to be, a little puppy can say "Yes sir,
>>>> my beloved CCP".
>>>> “That's why Zhang has been making some silly movies like "Hero"...What
>>>> a waste! “
>>>> Don't you see "Now" in the above sentence, I provided you CURRENT
>>>> status of Zhang Yimou, a puppy to CCP, making silly movies like "Hero"
>>>> etc so he will not offend CCP. But you simply do not read.
>
>>>> NOTHING you wrote bears any resemblance whatsoever to answering what I
>>>> asked! I have just shown this thread to your Taiwan compatriots, and
>>>> they all laughed at you. They went so far as to say that you are a
>>>> lunatic. Are you suffering from pms?
>
>>>> Hey, Tonto, go ask your Kimo Sabe Walsh!
>
>>>>> On Aug 13, 12:34 pm, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>>>>>> On Aug 13, 4:43 pm, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>>>>>> Also, don't tell me what other Taiwanese think. Vast majority of
>>>>>>> Taiwanese are for status quo, ie, no TI no Unification. President Ma
>>>>>>> also said no TI, no unification, no war during his term. Only 5-6%% of
>>>>>>> Taiwanese want "unification now" which is MUCH less from it was a
>>>>>>> decade ago. So think about it!
>
>>>>>>> And don't get me wrong, I highly praised economic achievement China
>>>>>>> has made last two decades but fully understand why China should focus
>>>>>>> on economy not political reform next two decades. But I just don't
>>>>>>> like you guys could not face the facts and have to twist, cover up
>>>>>>> dark side of China and attack those who speak the truth.
>
>>>>>>> BTW, one of my family members lives in Shanghai now. I have been to
>>>>>>> China many times, travelling many parts of China and have enjoyed it.
>>>>>>> But I just don't see any possibility for Taiwan be part of China
>>>>>>> anytime soon.
>
>>>>>> My question was, "In which parts of China are his (Zhang Yimou's) work
>>>>>> banned?", to Walsh's statement, "Nonsense. His work has been censored
>>>>>> and controlled and banned his whole life." You wrote all that rubbish
>>>>>> above, but not the answer.
>
>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 8:46 am, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 5:20 am, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>> Then you don't have any new question. And I have answered your
>>>>>>>>> question but it's you did not want to read. Like I said, *NOW* Zhang
>>>>>>>>> Yimou has behaved like a puppy to your beloved CCP.
>
>>>>>>>> Walsh wrote, "Nonsense. His work has been censored and controlled and
>>>>>>>> banned his whole life."
>
>>>>>>>> I asked, "In which parts of China are his work banned?" Notice that
>>>>>>>> neither Walsh nor I were using the past tense.
>
>>>>>>>> You answered for Walsh, "Some of Zhang Yimou's movies were banned in
>>>>>>>> China and also 2-year ban on filmmaking from 1994."
>>>>>>>> You then went on to copy and paste, "The films dealing with the pre-
>>>>>>>> revolutionary era seek to explore the authoritarian and patriarchal
>>>>>>>> relations of the 1920s and 30s, revealing the cruelty and ignorance in
>>>>>>>> ruling institutions also prevalent in today's China. These
>>>>>>>> metaphorical depictions have obviously disturbed the sensitivities of
>>>>>>>> the Chinese establishment. The films have been heavily criticized and
>>>>>>>> some of them even banned, like Ju Dou and Raise the Red Lantern. All
>>>>>>>> the above-mentioned films earned him a 2-year ban on filmmaking from
>>>>>>>> 1994."
>
>>>>>>>> You haven't answered my question, even when you tried to cover up for
>>>>>>>> Walsh. You showed no hesitation in repeating your stupid posts over
>>>>>>>> and over again, but you can't even answer a simple direct question.
>>>>>>>> Why is that? I know many Chinese from Taiwan here in New York, and
>>>>>>>> they have become my good friends - none of them behaves the way you
>>>>>>>> do. Why is that? Is it because they are well-educated? They all regard
>>>>>>>> themselves as Chinese, not "Taiwanese". You couldn't have come out
>>>>>>>> from Taiwan of your own free will - you were simply kicked out for
>>>>>>>> being an idiot!
>
>>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 5:06 am, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 4:50 am, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>>>> What's your question? Like I said, I replied to your post just to
>>>>>>>>>>> remind you what happened to Zhang Yimou's filmmaking career in the
>>>>>>>>>>> 90s, that's all. By now, you should know your beloved CCP banned some
>>>>>>>>>>> of Zhang Yimou's movies and a 2-year ban on filmmaking from 1994. Or
>>>>>>>>>>> you could not face the fact for what your beloved CCP did to Zhang
>>>>>>>>>>> Yimou??? You tell us!
>
>>>>>>>>>> Just like I thought. You troll so much that you can't even remember
>>>>>>>>>> what you are trolling about. What an idiot you are!
>>>>>>>>>> I asked, "In which parts of China are his work banned?". You can't
>>>>>>>>>> even scroll up to look for it. What an utter imbecile you are!
>>>>>>>>>> So you are beginning to have you paranoiac seizures again and accuse
>>>>>>>>>> people of being the same poster?
>
>>>>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 4:45 am, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 4:33 am, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>>>>>> Oh just to remind you what happened to Zhang Yimou's filmmaking career
>>>>>>>>>>>>> in the 90s, that's all. By now, you should know your beloved CCP
>>>>>>>>>>>>> banned some of Zhang Yimou's movies and a 2-year ban on filmmaking
>>>>>>>>>>>>> from 1994. Now, just like you, Zhang Yimou has behaved like a puppy to
>>>>>>>>>>>>> CCP. That's what your CCP wants you to be, a little puppy can say "Yes
>>>>>>>>>>>>> sir, my beloved CCP".
>
>>>>>>>>>>>> You still can't answer my simple question. All you can do is go round
>>>>>>>>>>>> and round, but cannot answer a simple question. You show yourself to
>>>>>>>>>>>> be a moron with every single post you write. You use pseudonyms that
>>>>>>>>>>>> reflect people in power. Were you so abused by your stepfather (you
>>>>>>>>>>>> never knew your biological father) that you hate anyone that has
>>>>>>>>>>>> power, position, and success? You must be a failed man, just like
>>>>>>>>>>>> Walsh!
>
>>>>>>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 4:28 am, Dragon newyork.com> wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On Aug 13, 4:12 am, hu.jt.ch...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Zhang Yimou has learned a hard lesson from the 90s of his filmmaking
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> career, that is, don't make films that Chinese government does not
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> like. That's why Zhang has been making some silly movies like
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "Hero"... What a waste! Of course, Chinese government likes that. a
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> talented filmmaker has become a silly filmmaker, Zhang Yimou! And
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Chinese government also welcomes Chinese people like you, a
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> brainwashed Chinese man, unconditional obedience to his CCP master.
>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> If you want to
>
> ...
>
> read more »- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!

RELATED THREADS
SubjectArticles qty Group
Re: Nyt fra Yimou Zhang (Hero / House of Flying Daggers)dk.kultur.film ·