On Aug 6, 8:38 pm, abian_c...@
yahoo.com wrote:
> That's right. In the states, you can watch great concerts, say, from
> Great Performances at PBS. And in China, CCTV also broadcasts great
> concerts from the west. So when "Danish Opera Singer" boasted he was
> hailed as a hero in China, I simply don't believe it. Chinese people
> are not that dumb, they can tell who's accomplished musican, who's
> not. That person boasted himself out of proportion!!!
>
> Chinese saying "Before you boast, don't forget to write a script so
> that at least it can make some sense!" 吹牛也要草稿吧!!!
>
> He is fooling nobody except his supporters from rec.music.opera and
> those thugs from soc.culture.china.
>
> On Aug 6, 8:16 pm, ltlee1 hotmail.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>> On Aug 6, 1:07 am, James T hotmail.com> wrote:
>
>>> On Aug 5, 5:22 pm, "abianc...@
my-deja.com"
my-deja.com>
>>> wrote:
>
>>>> With his music "career" and those videos he posted, I doubt J. Venning
>>>> was hailed as a hero in China as he boasted.
>
>>>> "I have sung in Beijing twice now, and each time, I was hailed as a
>>>> hero returning to his Motherland by the audiences." - J. Venning, Jan.
>>>> 16, 2006
>
>>>> Otherwise, Chinese government would have invited him to sing in their
>>>> Concert Hall instead of in that shabby place in Beijing.
>
>>>> On Aug 5, 6:19 pm, The Riff Raff yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>
>>>>> On 5 Aug, 22:56, "abianc...@
my-deja.com"
my-deja.com>
>>>>> wrote:> J, Venning is 3rd rate musician (too be polite) and he boasted he was
>>>>>> hailed as a hero in China. If that's true, Chinese government would
>>>>>> have invited him to sing in their Concert Hall in Beijing instead of
>>>>>> that shabby place. He posted several singing videos in youtube, they
>>>>>> are pathetic!!! Are they the best "performance" that J. Venning ever
>>>>>> gave??? If so, that's sad!
>
>>>>>> It's ok to be 3rd rate musician but don't fool people by claiming he
>>>>>> is hero in China. I don't think Chinese people are that stupid!!!
>>>>>>==========
>
>>> Why have you not answered any of the questions people asked you on
>>> this thread which you started? How many operas have you seen to pass
>>> judgment on the quality of a performance? I have admitted that I don't
>>> like opera, but even then I have seen a few to come to that
>>> conclusion. Where is this supposedly "shabby place" you think the
>>> performance took place? You don't seem to able to answer any questions
>>> - is it because you cannot understand the questions posed? Or is
>>> because you are only interested in flaming and insulting, but nothing
>>> else on this newsgroup? You keep on saying that J.Venning is "3rd
>>> rate". I couldn't care less what rate you think he is, but at least he
>>> is making a living doing his job. What sort of work do you do to earn
>>> your living?
>
>> As far as I can tell, Abianchen is living in America. So opera is a
>> freqent event. Public TV shows two three times every year. Probably
>> from the Lincoln Center, the Kennedy Center, and or the Carneige Hall.
>> If he is an average American, he is likely to watch a few on the TV.
>
>>>>> Okay...if Mr Venning is so bad...
>>>>> Let's see and hear YOU do better!- Hide quoted text -
>
>>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>
>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>
>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>
>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>
>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
Those of us in rec. music opera are not "fooled." We are a musical
group, not a political group. As a musician, we enjoy and we respect
Mr. Venning. In our group, his opinions are valuable, and his
performances, when he chooses to share them, are fun.
Unless you are commenting ONLY on the music, please stop cross-posting
to us. Thank you.
And should I respond again, I will respond only on RMO.
Paul