cargo cults
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
soc.atheism only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

soc.atheism Profile…
 Up
cargo cults         


Author: Allan Adler
Date: Feb 21, 2008 19:15

How do we know that the objects collected and used by cargo cults
have religious significance, rather than merely artistic significance
which the people take very seriously?
--
Ignorantly,
Allan Adler zurich.csail.mit.edu>
* Disclaimer: I am a guest and *not* a member of the MIT CSAIL. My actions and
* comments do not reflect in any way on MIT. Also, I am nowhere near Boston.
3 Comments
Re: cargo cults         


Author: Ben Goren
Date: Feb 21, 2008 19:59

Allan Adler wrote:
> How do we know that the objects collected and used by cargo
> cults have religious significance, rather than merely artistic
> significance which the people take very seriously?

Not being an expert on the matter, I'd start with any of the dozen
sources spanning a half-century listed at Wikipedia if it was a
serious scholarly answer I was looking for.

But being just an ordinary schmuck, I'm personally satisfied with
the sort of thing that you find in the Smithsonian Magazine
article on the subject. I see nothing whatsoever ``artistic''
in their descriptions of the people's beliefs, and everything
``religious.''

Draw your own conclusions.

Cheers,

b&

--
EAC Memographer
BAAWA Knight of Blasphemy
``All but God can prove this sentence true.''
no comments
Re: cargo cults         


Author: Apostate
Date: Feb 21, 2008 20:49

In article nestle.csail.mit.edu>, Allan Adler says...
> How do we know that the objects collected and used by cargo cults
> have religious significance, rather than merely artistic significance
> which the people take very seriously?
>

Ask a devotee?

(By now, some may be Useneteers. Maybe one will respond to your
query.)

--
Apostate a.a. #1931
.sig currently undergoing maintenance
mail to X-mailto; Yeehaw = what BillG
wants to coerce into a merger
no comments
Re: cargo cults         


Date: Feb 23, 2008 08:10

"Allan Adler" nestle.csail.mit.edu> wrote in message
news:y9363whk7h3.fsf@nestle.csail.mit.edu...
> How do we know that the objects collected and used by cargo cults
> have religious significance, rather than merely artistic significance
> which the people take very seriously?

If my understanding is correct, if you ask them what they get out of it,
they reply, "Hopefully, cargo", and not "Artistic edification".

--

Regards,
Mike Combs
----------------------------------------------------------------------
By all that you hold dear on this good Earth
I bid you stand, Men of the West!
Aragorn
no comments