Re: Hunting in dangerous water
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
sci.anthropology.paleo only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

 Up
Re: Hunting in dangerous water         

Group: sci.anthropology.paleo · Group Profile
Author: Lee Olsen
Date: Apr 21, 2008 18:27

On Apr 21, 5:53В pm, Day Brown hughes.net> wrote:
> On Apr 21, 6:11 pm, Lee Olsen hotmail.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>> "Here's a point to consider when evaluating AAT. I did not learn this
>> point from some academic overlord with an anti-AAT agenda; I learned
>> it while trying to avoid becoming crocodile food in Africa. When I
>> spent several months with a team at Lake Turkana, Kenya, investigating
>> some of the most important early hominid sites in the world, one of
>> our overriding concerns -- while swimming, bathing, or catching fish
>> with a net -- was to watch out for crocodiles in the shallows. A croc
>> can be on you, crush your legs in its jaws, and drag you under to
>> drown before you have time to screech for help.
>
>> The fact that crocodiles co-existed in time and space with early
>> hominids is a colossal blow to AAT, which does not explain what
>> advantages early humans would have gained by spending time in
>> crocodile-populated waters; an environment where they could not make
>> fires, throw stones or sticks, use other tools, or have any hope
>> whatever of escaping the most common predator. A troop of early
>> hominids wading in a lakeshore or swampy forest would best be
>> described as a crocodile banquet. The cute, feel-good images of babies
>> swimming freely in a pool, shown in the AAT video, have nothing to do
>> with the real situation of predator avoidance in Africa. Ask the
>> Dasenich or Turkana people who live around Lake Turkana: only visiting
>> maniacs swim in that lake." Cameron M. Smith
>
> As usual, this characterization ignores the widely varied adaptability
> of hominids.

Another lip-service reply, lacking any sort of data. Nothing but the
usual, know nothing tripe.

Su Solomon has been there, Smilth has been there, they say different,
but you know better than they?

http://tinyurl.com/y44rnt

"Mind you, its amazing how people can delude themselves into
believing
the impossible! And I would put the: "nah I wont get taken by a croc,
'cause the crocs are small and not there etc. into the class called:
'logical fantasies". This can be believed by the most "intelligent"
people, including Johanson! I was doing a dig at Alia Bay (south of
Koobi Fora) in '87, and each afternoon when we finished for the day,
we
would go down to the shores of Lake Turkana and have a wash. People
("intelligent white people") would throw themselves in the water and
swim and wash, I stayed at the back in knee deep water, praying that
if
there were any crocs around at the time, they would take the stupid
"B's" who were further out!" Su Solomon

Davidson, I. & Solomon, S. (1990) Was OH 27 the victim of a crocodile
attack?. In Solomon, S., Davidson, I. & Watson, D. (eds) Problem
Solving in Taphonomy: Archaeological & Palaeontological Studies from
Europe, Africa & Oceania. Tempus 2. Anthropology Museum, University
of
Queensland, St. Lucia, Queensland. 198 - 206.
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!