The right order
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.music.progressive only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

rec.music.progressive Profile…
 Up
The right order         


Author: clueidiota
Date: Jul 24, 2006 19:34

Greatest rock bands of all time.

1. Led Zeppelin
2. Yes
3. Pink Floyd
.
.
.
400. Beatles

Yeah, Beatles suck. I like a bunch of their songs still . But they are
still quite possibly the most overrated band on earth.

None of their album were perfect. Every album has 2-3 filler songs or
even more. The initial albums were junk.

1) Please Please me: 3/10 (three good songs - Twist and Shout, I saw
her Standing there and Love me Do.... rest junk)

2) With the Beatles: 0/10 (all mediocre songs... WORST ALBUM ever)

3) A Hard Days Night: 3/10 (three good songs - A hard days night, And
I love her, Cant buy me love)

4) Beatles for Sale: 3/10 (Again!!! only three good songs - Babys in
Black, Eight days a week, Every little thing)
Show full article (2.17Kb)
46 Comments
Re: The right order         


Author: fishandchipp
Date: Jul 24, 2006 20:07

> they were very popular but never great.

I guess the whole world went into a Beatle trance all at once.

Show us your songs, better yet , link us to your credentials.
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: a
Date: Jul 24, 2006 20:14

On 24 Jul 2006 19:34:34 -0700, clueidiota@yahoo.com wrote:
>Greatest rock bands of all time.
>
>1. Led Zeppelin
>2. Yes
>3. Pink Floyd
>.
>.
>.
>400. Beatles
>
>Yeah, Beatles suck. I like a bunch of their songs still . But they are
>still quite possibly the most...
Show full article (2.37Kb)
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: Happ_e_maker
Date: Jul 24, 2006 20:12

Yes, Led Zeppelin, and, even Pink Floyd at a certain point had at least 1 or
2 weak albums. I can't stand Tormato, Piper at the Gates of Dawn and Coda.
On the other hand, all beatles albums are at least listenable, if not good,
pretty good or excellent.
Let It Be is their Swang. Carry that Weigth and Long and Winding road are
pretty good songs, besides Let it Be and Get Back.
The fact is that the Beatles do not belong to the same music category as the
3 other bands belong. They should not be compared together.

yahoo.com> a
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: tysteel3000
Date: Jul 24, 2006 20:50

clueidiota@yahoo.com wrote:
> Greatest rock bands of all time.
>
> 1. Led Zeppelin
> 2. Yes
> 3. Pink Floyd
> .
> .
> .
> 400. Beatles
>
> Yeah, Beatles suck. I like a bunch of their songs still . But they are
> still quite possibly the most overrated band on earth.

And the kooks here say I'm crazy? The beatles are the greatest band
of all time, if not for their music, then for how they paved the way
for every other band that came after. They certainly are the most
popular. Beatles songs have great melodies; I really enjoy playing
their songs myself on the piano. Wish I had more time to do it.
Show full article (1.65Kb)
2 Comments
Re: The right order         


Author: clueidiota
Date: Jul 24, 2006 21:00

Wes wrote:
> I'm just happy he didn't fill in 4-399.

dont tempt me...
>
> Wes
>
> "Happ e maker" hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:G fxg.9529$Hq5.212137@wagner.videotron.net...
>> Yes, Led Zeppelin, and, even Pink Floyd at a certain point had at least 1...
Show full article (3.34Kb)
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: capolk
Date: Jul 24, 2006 21:01

On 24 Jul 2006 20:50:51 -0700, tysteel3000@aol.com wrote:
>clueidiota@yahoo.com wrote:
>> Yeah, Beatles suck. I like a bunch of their songs still . But they are
>> still quite possibly the most overrated band on earth.
>And the kooks here say I'm crazy? The beatles are the greatest band
>of all time, if not for their music, then for how they paved the way
>for every other band that came after. They certainly are the most
>popular. Beatles songs have great melodies; I really enjoy playing
>their songs myself on the piano. Wish I had more time to do it.

Wish you had more time to listen to some other artists, too.

The dude IS an idiot - but they ARE overrated. Which is not their
fault. More the fault of people like yourself. Although you do balance
out this guy, so all remains (relatively) harmonious in the world.
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: draw Tippy
Date: Jul 24, 2006 21:55

"Rush'07" eric.com> wrote in message
>> Yes is wankery

Dave the Cook wrote:
> LMAO, and you're basing this on......?

He based on years of experience at wanking.
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: timagine
Date: Jul 24, 2006 21:57

What you know about music would lose out to a doorbell.

voice from the past

clueidiota@yahoo.com wrote:
> Greatest rock bands of all time.
>
> 1. Led Zeppelin
> 2. Yes
> 3. Pink Floyd
> .
> .
> .
> 400. Beatles
>
> Yeah, Beatles suck. I like a bunch of their songs still . But...
Show full article (2.38Kb)
no comments
Re: The right order         


Author: Lane
Date: Jul 25, 2006 03:43

Greastest in what way? Sellings, artistic, listeners, quality, clompexity or
simplicity and so on.

I respect your "greatest thing", but it can't be 'measured'. With what
standards do you measure?

Lane
no comments
1 2 3 4 5