Re: No, THESE are the 100 greatest British artists ever?
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.music.progressive only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: No, THESE are the 100 greatest British artists ever?         

Group: rec.music.progressive · Group Profile
Author: zepfloyes
Date: May 25, 2008 19:36

On May 25, 4:21 pm, poisoned rose definitive.com> wrote:
> Since that previously posted Digital Dream Door list was so awful, I
> decided to take a shot at the task myself. I know the original list
> specified "rock" artists, but simply reading the list (Robbie Williams,
> Depeche Mode, Phil Collins, Eurythmics, Herman's Hermits, Massive
> Attack, Cat Stevens, etc.) showed that this limitation was not truly
> followed.
>
> I hasten to point out that these are *not* just my personal favorites.
> In fact, I own albums by a mere 47 of these 100 names. I even sharply
> dislike several of them (Billy Idol and Happy Mondays, for
> instance...BLECCH). I also tried to give some respectful love to acts
> such as Cliff Richard, Pulp, the Jam, Massive Attack and Manic Street
> Preachers which were hugely important in the UK but had lesser US
> success.
>
> I also moaned to omit many personal favorites such as Wire, Robyn
> Hitchcock/Soft Boys, Brian Eno, Richard Thompson, the Fall, Syd Barrett,
> Spiritualized, the Move and Magazine, but just felt they were too
> "cultish" to warrant a rank.
>
> I did not refer to the DDD site while compiling the below, but I now see
> that I repeated 64 names from that list. Which is actually a few more
> than expected (I originally estimated that the DDD list was about "half"
> accurate). And that's not even taking into account that I ruled out Jimi
> Hendrix Experience and Rod Stewart on sheer nationality grounds (I did
> decide to grudgingly allow Fleetwood Mac).
>
> Final note: Given the other list's heavy '70s-rawker orientation, I'm
> very surprised it did not include Bad Company or Mott the Hoople.
> Someone at DDD must really hate Mick Ralphs!
>
> So, dissect this list if you like. But please, try to have some
> perspective which goes beyond your own emotional, fannish preferences.
> And be aware that nationality quibbles are the dullest possible route
> which the discussion could take. And I don't pretend that these names
> are in absolute, perfect order, so if you merely want someone moved up
> or down a few slots....
>
> And Raja, if you MUST reply (and I really don't care if you do), see if
> you can base your argument on something beyond sheer attitude and
> "loudness."
>
> 1. The Beatles
> 2. The Rolling Stones
> 3. Led Zeppelin
> 4. Pink Floyd
> 5. Elton John
> 6. The Who
> 7. David Bowie
> 8. The Clash
> 9. Queen
> 10.   Paul McCartney
> 11.   The Kinks
> 12.   John Lennon
> 13.   Eric Clapton
> 14.   Sting
> 15.   Elvis Costello
> 16.   The Sex Pistols
> 17.   The Police
> 18.   The Smiths
> 19.   Radiohead
> 20.   Fleetwood Mac
> 21.   Cream
> 22.   The Yardbirds
> 23.   Oasis
> 24.   Genesis
> 25.   Depeche Mode
> 26.   Morrissey
> 27.   The Cure
> 28.   Duran Duran
> 29.   Peter Gabriel
> 30.   Black Sabbath
> 31.   The Animals
> 32.   Yes
> 33.   Roxy Music
> 34.   Eurythmics
> 35.   New Order
> 36.   Siouxsie & the Banshees
> 37.   The Jam
> 38.   Jethro Tull
> 39.   The Moody Blues
> 40.   T. Rex
> 41.   Coldplay
> 42.   Echo & the Bunnymen
> 43.   Deep Purple
> 44.   Iron Maiden
> 45.   Dusty Springfield
> 46.   Cliff Richard
> 47.   Bauhaus
> 48.   The Buzzcocks
> 49.   Cat Stevens
> 50.   Def Leppard
> 51.   Ozzy Osbourne
> 52.   Petula Clark
> 53.   Robbie Williams
> 54.   Frankie Goes to Hollywood
> 55.   The Hollies
> 56.   Traffic
> 57.   Electric Light Orchestra
> 58.   The Dave Clark Five
> 59.   George Michael
> 60.   Blur
> 61.   Joy Division
> 62.   Public Image Ltd.
> 63.   Phil Collins
> 64.   Bad Company
> 65.   Joe Cocker
> 66.   The Zombies
> 67.   Motorhead
> 68.   XTC
> 69.   The Stone Roses
> 70.   Massive Attack
> 71.   Jeff Beck
> 72.   P J Harvey
> 73.   The Faces
> 74.   Emerson, Lake & Palmer
> 75.   Kate Bush
> 76.   Pulp
> 77.   King Crimson
> 78.   Procol Harum
> 79.   Judas Priest
> 80.   Fairport Convention
> 81.   Dire Straits
> 82.   Pet Shop Boys
> 83.   George Harrison
> 84.   Happy Mondays
> 85.   The Human League
> 86.   The Style Council
> 87.   The Verve
> 88.   UB40
> 89.   Billy Idol
> 90.   Madness
> 91.   Supertramp
> 92.   Squeeze
> 93.   Gang of Four
> 94.   The Damned
> 95.   Mott the Hoople
> 96.   Graham Parker
> 97.   The Specials
> 98.   The (English) Beat
> 99.   Manic Street Preachers
> 100.  Joe Jackson
>
> The top names which I just couldn't find room for:
> Bryan Ferry, the Fall, the Spencer Davis Group, the Sweet, Primal Scream

This was my chance to lash out at you. The way you do on every list at
you. But I am gonna blow it away. This list is very good. I like it. I
just imagine certain things.

Bahaus > Joy Division? Joy Division were a lot more important than
them, had a lot more great songs and were much more original. Bahaus
might be infact very much influenced by JD.

You have give too much importance to pop and soft rock. I dont think
pop acts like George Michael belong in the same list as Black Sabbath.
They should be on seperate lists. And I am a little surprised Genesis
is ahead of Yes in your mind. Genesis 80s shouldnt count for them in
any way. And in any case Yes 90125 could blow away all the pop albums
of Genesis combined.
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!