| Re: 3 left in Pink Floyd now... 2 (Rick and Syd) gone to Heaven |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
Group: rec.music.progressive · Group Profile
Author: RajaRaja Date: Sep 19, 2008 16:07
On Sep 19, 5:39В pm, poisoned rose usenet.com>
wrote:>>> You love Led Zeppelin, and they had some songs which include keyboard
>>> parts. End of story.
>
>> Keep repeating it, it might one day become true.
>
> Let's see...being a moronic Led Zeppelin fanboy, you contend that JPJ is
> "easily" among the top five keyboardists ever. Which suggests he's in
> the top four at worst.
Of course. You figured that one out, braniac?
>
> Then, who are your top three? Two Yes keyboardists and Richard Wright,
> just because they're in your other two favorite bands?
My top 10 would be something like....
1. Rick Wakeman
2. Rick Wright
3. Keith Emerson
4. John Lord
5. John Paul Jones
6. Patrick Moraz
7. Ray Manzarek
8. Hugh Banton
9. Rod Argent
10. Mike Pinder
The other two Yes keyboardists Tony Kaye and Geoff Downes were very
good as well and they could be in the top 20. Most Yes keyboardists
are great, they dont hire dummies.
> Or do you take a
> startling leap of diversity and insert some OTHER keyboardist from a
> '70s classic-rock band?
| 
