Re: 3 left in Pink Floyd now... 2 (Rick and Syd) gone to Heaven
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.music.progressive only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: 3 left in Pink Floyd now... 2 (Rick and Syd) gone to Heaven         

Group: rec.music.progressive · Group Profile
Author: Raja
Date: Sep 18, 2008 10:04

On Sep 16, 2:35 pm, poisoned rose usenet.com>
wrote:
> Raja gmail.com> wrote:
>>>>> What would you say are his most dazzling keyboard showcases, such that
>>>>> he deserves stature among the all-time greats?
>
>>>> His piano and organ work on Pow R Toc H and Take Thy Stethescope and
>>>> walk are breathtaking. He was excellent in Astronomy Domine and
>>>> Interstellar Overdrive (but Syd kinda overshadows him with his guitar
>>>> brilliance on those two). I like Rick's effort on See Saw (IMO the
>>>> best song solely written by Rick before The Dark Side of the Moon).
>>>> Also AHM suite and Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast have some great
>>>> keyboard work.
>
>>> Get back to us when you've heard some true keyboard giants. Thanks.
>
>> And those are? I like Keith Emerson, John Lord and Rick Wakeman as
>> well.
>
> You know nothing.
>
> You like a tiny set of "bands," and hence will answer any such "best"
> question in terms of those bands.
>
> I'm surprised you're not claiming John Paul Jones isn't one of the
> world's great keyboardists too.

Yes he is. Easily top 5. But he didnt play much keyboard.
>
>>> Didn't say that at all. But I don't think Wright even registered much as
>>> a "stylist," as compared with some other players.
>
>> And who are these, douche?
>
> Just people whom you wouldn't be able to discuss. Don't worry your ugly
> little head about them.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!