Re: 100 Greatest British albums of all time
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.music.progressive only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: 100 Greatest British albums of all time         

Group: rec.music.progressive · Group Profile
Author: Wes
Date: Dec 26, 2006 21:50

Using *then* for *than* is not a typo. Considering the sloppy and illiterate
presentation, why should we evaluate your opinions any differently *then*
the presentation?

You have offered opinions. One German announcer does not initiate
Progressive Rock, or what is considered Progressive Rock, upon the world.

If you like The Yardbirds, that's great. They were a fine rock band. They
were not a Progressive Rock Band. You might say they approached the blues a
bit differently than the traditional path taken. You could say the same
about Jimi Hendrix. The JHE wasn't a Progressive Band either. One quote on
an album sleeve does not herald the Progressive Rock genre.

I think you need to demonstrate the where the phrases *Progressive Rock* and
*Experimental Rock* appeared routinely in the common vernacular a year prior
to *Psychedelic Rock*.

Wes

"Yelps" worldsiliyeti.net> wrote in message
news:I6CdnR9SNIA3nQ_YnZ2dnUVZ_vGinZ2d@adelphia.com...
>
> "Wes" suite224.net> wrote in message
> news:4591d9fa$0$4963$e656108c@news.suite224.net...
>>I knew it was a great post when massive grammar errors occur by the second
>>sentence and continue throughout the post.
>>
>> What evidence is there that experimental and progressive rock preceded
>> psychedelia?
>>
>> Wes
>
> I don't apologize for my typoes unless you want to pay me for the words.
> I'll edit when I am being paid for it.
>
> The evidence that "experimental and progressive rock preceded
> psychedelia?" is the simple reality as I said that these terms where being
> used by commentators to describe the Yardbirds or there own descriptions
> of themselves. See the liner notes on the original "Having a Rave up with
> the Yardbirds." and virtually any old music magazine article about them in
> 1964and 1965 in the UK or 1965 in the US.
>
> Listen to what the announcer says in German at the beginning of this
> video tape annoucing the Yardbirds from 1967.
>
> http://www.yelpsastound.com/MUSIC/Yardbirds%%201967.wmv
>
> The Yardbirds were always known as "progressive/experimental" and in those
> years this is what they were called conversationally. No other rock group
> was called this, till Pink Floyd a little later, when they were doing
> their first amateur quality "electronic music," copying the "electronics
> music" sound ala the Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center from the
> 50's.
>
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbia-Princeton_Electronic_Music_Center
>
> In 1966 the first use of the term "psychedelic:" on an music single on
> the sleeve of UK's version of Happening Ten Years Time Ago.
>
> dc
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>>
>> "ZepFloYes" yahoo.com> wrote in message
>> news:1167173863.635529.105570@48g2000cwx.googlegroups.com...
>>>
>>> Yelps wrote:
>>>> "Tony Elka" shadowlane.com> wrote in message
>>>> news:shadowlane-DFA022.11155126122006@news.newsguy.com...
>>>>> In article <1167153270.605760.216340@42g2000cwt.googlegroups.com>,
>>>>> zepfloyes@yahoo.com wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> That doesnt mean that I completely agree with the list. There are
>>>>>> several flaws on the list. No Moody Blues, come on! And where is
>>>>>> "The
>>>>>> Piper At the Gates of Dawn'!
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Perhaps there's something inherently ridiculous about the very
>>>>> concept
>>>>> of these lists?
>>>>>
>>>>> Tony<<<<<<<<<<<
>>>>
>>>> Inherently flawed yes.
>>>>
>>>> Being a few years older then most people commenting on these
>>>> threads---being
>>>> a 60's person rather then a 70's or 80's person---and i read the
>>>> various
>>>> opinions I am always aware of the evolution of rock from the 50's into
>>>> the
>>>> 60's and from the 60's to the 70's and beyond. There are very real
>>>> influences that built one upon the other. People who were attuned to
>>>> the
>>>> 70's and 80's---most of the Rock list writers I see on the internet,
>>>> don't
>>>> seem to be aware of how these developments built on each other and
>>>> where the
>>>> deciding influences came from. I could write a book on the subject,
>>>> but
>>>> probably never will, but it really annoys me, that younger then me rock
>>>> fans
>>>> and historians, get so much of it wrong. One of the key points to
>>>> really
>>>> understand influences in music, is to understand how there is a
>>>> critical age
>>>> of the listener, when that listener is most malleable to music. It is
>>>> like
>>>> a bonding and imprinting process.
>>>>
>>>> For instance, my generation was a little too young when Elvis came out,
>>>> to
>>>> bond to Elvis music, so although I later learned to appreciate Elvis in
>>>> his
>>>> films a bit and liked some of the songs--he and his fans were like an
>>>> old
>>>> fogey to me. I remember when a older brother of one of my friends
>>>> showed me
>>>> an early Elvis album that he was bonded to, my immediate reaction to
>>>> just
>>>> seeing the album cover with the photo of Elvis standing there, was to
>>>> see
>>>> Elvis as a "greaser" from the old 50's crowd--the kind of music I would
>>>> hear
>>>> on the pop radio at the time, which was all about love songs and things
>>>> of a
>>>> adolescent romantic nature---while at the time I had not yet even hit
>>>> puberty. Puberty itself tends to intensify the romantic pop songs and
>>>> does
>>>> so taody as well. Most of the top 40 is always in this category.
>>>>
>>>> The next most important thing to understand is the drugs of choice of a
>>>> generation and how it effects the generation and the music. Drugs
>>>> themselves
>>>> intensify the imprinting. In the case of the mid 60's to the end of
>>>> the
>>>> 60's, it was LSD, a decidedly different kind of drug from alcohol,
>>>> speed,
>>>> cocaine, heroin, etc. This is why the so called progressive and
>>>> psychedelic
>>>> music appeared--vastly different from the previous kinds of music, both
>>>> lyrically and instrumentally. In the 60's between 1965-1969, before
>>>> the
>>>> shit hit the fan, the sound tended to be speaking to the millions of
>>>> young
>>>> people whose consciousness had been substantially altered by LSD. Jeff
>>>> Beck
>>>> and the Yardbirds, changed the sound of the electric guitar and it was
>>>> like
>>>> a signal that reached all the people who had tried acid or used it
>>>> regularly. From that moment ALL the rock bands changed overnight.
>>>> Kubrick's
>>>> 2001 also was major signal in the other main media--films---and even if
>>>> people hated it, or hated LSD, once the signal was sent there was an
>>>> unconscious change. Once the LSD era was mostly passed, things
>>>> reverted
>>>> back, but leaving only the form of the music--i.e., the loud sustained
>>>> guitar riffs--even though the lyrics then began to lose their
>>>> psychedelic
>>>> nature and revert back to pop romance and alcohol, amphetamine, Cocaine
>>>> or
>>>> heroin based music. The mass generation LSD/Psychedelic period was
>>>> really
>>>> a very brief era. To existing English bands like the Beatles, Stones,
>>>> Yardbirds, and the Who and then Pink Floyd and others there is
>>>> literally an
>>>> overnight change in the content and it spread in the US like a
>>>> wildfire.
>>>>
>>>> The phrases "progressive rock," and "experimental rock" preceded the
>>>> psychedelic period by about one year. 1964 was the year people first
>>>> heard
>>>> that weird progressive/experimental rock when they heard the Yardbirds
>>>> who
>>>> were substantially different in their live sound, from the Beatles,
>>>> Stones
>>>> and Animals or Kinks. This happened in 1964 in the UK. The first time
>>>> that
>>>> phrase was heard was about the Yardbirds and did not appply to any of
>>>> the
>>>> other bands, but it was said conversationally not as terms. then,
>>>> before
>>>> that could even thought of as a category of rock, we were in the
>>>> Psychedelic
>>>> period, beginning in 1965, which brough the terms "progressive" and
>>>> "experimental" with it "Still I'm Sad" and "I'm a Man" and "Mister
>>>> you're a
>>>> Better man then I," and "Heart full of Soul," guitar solo, were the
>>>> first
>>>> studio tracks of progressive/experimental rock. These phrases, were
>>>> used by
>>>> any commentators, describing the Yardbirds at the time. Hearing
>>>> "Still I'm
>>>> Sad," on the pop radio signaled a major change in music. Hearing the
>>>> Guitar solo in "Heartful of Soul" and "Mister you're a better man then
>>>> I"
>>>> was the very beginning of heavy metal psychedelic guitar and this all
>>>> corresponded with the exact moment in time, many people in Los Angeles
>>>> and
>>>> around the world, were first experimenting with LSD and the fact is, on
>>>> LSD
>>>> a person responds immediatly to that kind of hypnotic guitar tone which
>>>> grabs the awareness and holds it. The Eastern Rage-like Music sound
>>>> began
>>>> to appear. Suddenly you had virtually every popular English band make
>>>> the
>>>> switch in guitar sound and a huge crop of US bands started to learn to
>>>> play
>>>> guitar, attempting to copy that sound. It was like the 100th Monkey
>>>> idea,
>>>> where the critical mass is reached and a new meme begins. Immediatly
>>>> after
>>>> that, there was the greatest wave of songs from each of the bands. It
>>>> was
>>>> like a brief Renaissance and for instance in Los Angeles we had three
>>>> main
>>>> "pop" radio channels and one could spin the dial and each of these
>>>> channels
>>>> was blasting this new paradigm onto Sunset boulevard, intermixed with
>>>> some
>>>> great soul music. You would hear the rave up, Im a Man, then change
>>>> to
>>>> "Tamborine Man" and Eight Miles High, then, "Satisfaction," then Dylans
>>>> "Like a Rolling Stone," then as the hour got later, into the evening,
>>>> you'd hear Zappa's "Who are the Brain Police," The bryds Turn turn
>>>> turn,
>>>> then Count Five's Psychotic Reaction" a juvenile, copycat Yardbird's
>>>> style
>>>> song, and then the concept albums were all appearing, and you'd hear
>>>> the SF
>>>> bands, mostly Grace Slick singing, "Go ask Alice," Donavan singing,
>>>> "Sunshine Superman and "The Trip" etc, the Mysterian's "96 Tears," The
>>>> Yardbirds again with Shapes of things, Over Under Sideways Down, and
>>>> "Happening ten years time ago" (all 1966) ...then came the Cream's I
>>>> feel
>>>> free, and "Sunshine of your love," the Doors, "Light My Fire," and
>>>> "Break on
>>>> through" etc. The Who's Magic Bus, Beatles, Sargent Pepper Yellow
>>>> Submarine albums (I am the Walrus) and the Who A quick One. "Boris the
>>>> Spider," etc. the Stones, "Paint it Black" and "She Comes in Colors"
>>>> and
>>>> "Get off my Cloud," Love's "7 and 7 Is," and many others of lesser
>>>> reknown.
>>>> It was an amazing time musically and it was all about inner exploration
>>>> with
>>>> LSD and the initial period of massive marijuana use. Then as the 60's
>>>> gave
>>>> way to the 70's there was a lot of mostly amateurish attempts at
>>>> copy cat
>>>> songs, until Zep came along with their first album and that was
>>>> followed
>>>> by a whole slew of increasingly non-psychedelicized, heavy metal and
>>>> Death
>>>> Metal as alchohol and cocaine appeared back on the scene. Romantic pop
>>>> started to return.
>>>>
>>>> Although at the time the era seemed like a long period, in retrospect
>>>> it was
>>>> very brief but very explosive time marked by significant changes
>>>> related to
>>>> actual world events.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Great post. I have always considered Yardbirds the first
>>> experimental/progressive/psychedelic band. Every band including the
>>> Beatles, Stones, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Who, Yes were were
>>> influenced by them.
>>>
>>>>
>>>> dc
>>>
>>
>>
>
>
9 Comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!