On 13 Jun, 21:08, Dontaitchic...@
aol.com wrote:
> On Jun 13, 2:52�pm, Kerrison yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
>> On 13 Jun, 19:44, Andrew Rose
pristineaudio.com> wrote:
>
>>> Andrew Rose wrote:
>>>> Only once did Toscanini programme an all-Debussy concert
>
>>> ...apart from the two he did with the NBC SO...
>
>>> (whoops!)
>
>>> --
>>> Andrew Rose - Pristine Classical
>
>
>> Quote: "Toscanini met Debussy for the first time in Paris in 1910, and
>> later corresponded with him on a number of occasions - including
>> asking for - and gaining - permission from the composer to adjust
>> aspects of the orchestration in La Mer with doublings and rebalancings
>> in order to improve the clarity of sound, particularly in the inner
>> voices. "
>
>> Could you please supply precise chapter and verse as to this
>> correspondence in the form of hard and fast evidence: that is to say,
>> the dates they corresponded, (day/month/year), and also exactly where
>> this actual correspondence can be seen or found. Additionally, if you
>> have photocopies in your own collection which you are citing here,
>> please let us know where you obtained them and from whom. Thanks.
>
> Â I assume that Andrew excerpted that from "The Letters of Arturo
> Toscanini compiled, edited, and translated by Harvey Sachs" (Alfred A.
> Knopf, New York, 2002). I have just looked at my copy's index; there
> are many, many entries about Toscanini and Debussy. I haven't had time
> to look up all of them. Regardless, I remember reading those words by
> Toscanini in Sachs's book.
>
> Â I'm sure that Andrew Rose will reply on his own.
>
> Â The book is of inestimable importance and should be purchased and
> read by anyone interested in this great musician and complicated, even
> tormented, man (Toscanini). I'll bet that you'd like Sachs's book a
> lot.
>
> Â Don Tait- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
I fear you assume incorrectly: there may indeed be many entries about
Toscanini and Debussy in Sach's book, which I've already consulted,
but none in respect of this alleged "permission" to tamper with La
Mer. Neither is there a single reference to it in any of the books on
Debussy, including the complete Debussy Letters as translated by Roger
Nichols (Faber & Faber 1987). This is why it will be especially
interesting to learn of the hard factual evidence, and the precise
location of the source material, that Mr Rose will doubtless supply.