Michelangeli
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.music.classical.recordings only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

rec.music.classical.recordings Profile…
 Up
Michelangeli         


Author: TareeDawg
Date: Nov 29, 2007 20:05

Having only recently heard Michelangeli's DG (Originals) disk of the
Op.10 Balladen of Brahms, Schubert's D537, and LvB's sonata Op.7, I
wonder if others more attuned to the pianistic world, would care to
comment on this high profile pianist, and possibly suggest the best
recordings that ABM has made.

Fwiw, I found that ABM's Ballades of sufficient quality (performance
wise) that I feel invited to want to explore them again. Precision, a
depth that is hiding beneath the surface is there, and the choice of the
LvB sonata is well chosen, and one of the sonatas of Ludwig that
actually appeals very much to these ears, and immaculately played to
boot. Cannot say I enjoyed his Schubert, more on account of the music as
much as anything.

Any comments welcome?

Ray (Dawg) Hall, Taree
18 Comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: Sol L. Siegel
Date: Nov 29, 2007 20:26

On Fri, 30 Nov 2007 15:05:14 +1100, TareeDawg bigpond.com>
wrote:
>Having only recently heard Michelangeli's DG (Originals) disk of the
>Op.10 Balladen of Brahms, Schubert's D537, and LvB's sonata Op.7, I
>wonder if others more attuned to the pianistic world, would...
Show full article (1.91Kb)
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: M. A.
Date: Nov 30, 2007 00:13

"TareeDawg" bigpond.com> wrote...
>
> Having only recently heard Michelangeli's DG (Originals) disk of the Op.10
> Balladen of Brahms, Schubert's D537, and LvB's sonata Op.7,
> I wonder if others more attuned to the pianistic world, would care to
> comment on this high profile pianist, and possibly suggest the best
> recordings that ABM has made.

If I had to pick just two discs, that would be his Chopin recital for DGG
(Ballade No. 1, Scherzo No. 2, Prélude Op. 45, ten Mazurkas) and the Warsaw
recital from 1955 on Altara (Bach/Busoni Chaconne, Brahms
Paganini-Variations, Schumann Piano Concerto). The Chopin recital stands out
for more or less the reasons you liked his Brahms/Beethoven (razor-sharp
precision and polish, yet with depth), while the Altara release, although in
atrocious sound, shows what an exciting pianist Michelangeli was when
playing staples of his repertoire live.

M. A.
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: JohnGavin
Date: Nov 30, 2007 01:10

On Nov 30, 3:13 am, "M. A." server.com> wrote:
> "TareeDawg" bigpond.com> wrote...
>
>> Having only recently heard Michelangeli's DG (Originals) disk of the Op.10
>> Balladen of Brahms, Schubert's D537, and LvB's sonata Op.7,
>> I wonder if others more attuned to the pianistic world, would care to
>> comment on this high profile pianist, and possibly suggest the best
>> recordings that ABM has made.
>
> If I had to pick just two discs, that would be his Chopin recital for DGG
> (Ballade No. 1, Scherzo No. 2, Prélude Op. 45, ten Mazurkas) and the Warsaw
> recital from 1955 on Altara (Bach/Busoni Chaconne, Brahms
> Paganini-Variations, Schumann Piano Concerto). The Chopin recital stands out
> for more or less the reasons you liked his Brahms/Beethoven (razor-sharp...
Show full article (1.59Kb)
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: M. A.
Date: Nov 30, 2007 07:39

"JohnGavin" comcast.net> wrote...
>
> On Nov 30, 3:13 am, "M. A." server.com> wrote:
>>
>> If I had to pick just two discs, that would be his Chopin recital for
>> DGG (Ballade No. 1, Scherzo No. 2, Prélude Op. 45, ten
>> Mazurkas) and the Warsaw recital from 1955 on Altara
>> (Bach/Busoni Chaconne, Brahms Paganini-Variations, Schumann
>> Piano Concerto). The Chopin recital stands out for more or less
>> the reasons you liked his Brahms/Beethoven (razor-sharp precision
>> and polish, yet with depth), while the Altara release, although in
>> atrocious sound, shows what an exciting pianist Michelangeli was
>> when playing staples of his repertoire live.
>
> Can't discuss Michelangeli's best without mentioning Debussy. Images
> I and II along with Children's Corner for DG and the Preludes I and II
> for DG are in a class by themselves - Also, perhaps the greatest
> recorded Grieg Concerto with Burgos on a BBC, a legendary Brahms
> Paganini Variations and Bach-Busoni Chaconne on EMI. His Chopin
> recital for DG is my single favorite Chopin CD. ...
Show full article (1.45Kb)
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: Paul Ilechko
Date: Nov 30, 2007 07:55

M. A. wrote:
> "JohnGavin" comcast.net> wrote...
>> Can't discuss Michelangeli's best without mentioning Debussy. Images
>> I and II along with Children's Corner for DG and the Preludes I and II
>> for DG are in a class by themselves - Also, perhaps the greatest
>> recorded Grieg Concerto with Burgos on a BBC, a legendary Brahms
>> Paganini Variations and Bach-Busoni Chaconne on EMI. His Chopin
>> recital for DG is my single favorite Chopin CD.
>
> His Debussy is indeed in class of its own, but in my taste at times to
> icy a class. While nowhere close to Michelangeli in terms of polish,
> Gieseking's Debussy is often more appealing to me.

If you like your Debussy played underwater ...
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: Paolo Pesenti
Date: Nov 30, 2007 10:18

On Nov 29, 11:05 pm, TareeDawg bigpond.com> wrote:
> Having only recently heard Michelangeli's DG (Originals) disk of the
> Op.10 Balladen of Brahms, Schubert's D537, and LvB's sonata Op.7, I
> wonder if others more attuned to the pianistic world, would care to
> comment on this high profile pianist, and possibly suggest the best
> recordings that ABM has made.

Let's see. The Ravel-Rachmaninov piano concertos on EMI, of course.
The London 1957 recital on Testament (including Schumann Carnaval and
Chopin Ballade 1). The Debussy recital on DG (Images and Children's...
Show full article (1.73Kb)
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: Andy Evans
Date: Nov 30, 2007 10:49

The only recording where I can't think of anyone better is the
Rachmaninov 4th, and that's only because the composer is in very old
sound. It's a great recording, no doubt at all.

I prefer Katchen in the Ravel (and like others as well, Bernstein,
Argerich, Collard etc) - I think this side of the pairing has been
overrated.

But yes, I do listen to his Debussy as one of many I like.

Chopin and the rest..... well, I listen to Michelangeli every once in
a while, but I wouldn't say he was a great Chopin pianist.

I prefer him to Pollini, but don't really listen to either. No soul,
really. Like marble - cold and elegant.
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: Rugby
Date: Nov 30, 2007 14:47

On Nov 30, 4:33 pm, Wayne Reimer pacbell.net> wrote:
>> In article < It was a bit of a shock to realize that I
> could listen to him, and with enjoyment, for years without really
> hearing what he was doing, and it was a real lesson in listener
> perception and how it can mislead.
>

Ah, so growing old does have its rewards !!

Now, if I can just listen to all the ABM's before the dementia sets
in !

Regards, Rugby
no comments
Re: Michelangeli         


Author: LaVirtuosa
Date: Nov 30, 2007 21:52

On Nov 30, 4:47�pm, Rugby gmail.com> wrote:
> On Nov 30, 4:33 pm, Wayne Reimer pacbell.net> wrote:
>
>>> In article < �It was a bit of a shock to realize that I
>> could listen to him, and with enjoyment, for years without really
>> hearing what he was doing, and it was a real lesson in listener
>> perception and how it can mislead.
>
> Ah, so growing old does have its rewards !!
>
> Now, if I can just listen to all the ABM's before the dementia sets
> in !
>
> Regards, Rugby

Remember not to forget the dvd's.

****Val
no comments
1 2