porcelain vs. stainless
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.food.equipment only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

rec.food.equipment Profile…
 Up
porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: KLS
Date: Nov 18, 2007 14:13

So, which do people think will "sell" a kitchen better: a nice white
Kohler porcelain double bowl sink or a stainless steel double bowl
sink? We're going to replace the counters and base cabinets and are
debating whether to recycle the Kohler we have now, which is a great
sink but does require work to keep spotless, or change it out for
stainless, which I worry will look too rental-unit-ish. I think we'll
be installing white subway tile on the backsplash wall in front of
that sink, which ought to look nice. What does the cohort think?
20 Comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Dee.Dee
Date: Nov 18, 2007 14:49

"KLS" suds.com> wrote in message
news:73e1k3l6ig00h9uuii1i1go6arq2k444nt@4ax.com...
> So, which do people think will "sell" a kitchen better: a nice white
> Kohler porcelain double bowl sink or a stainless steel double bowl
> sink? We're going to replace the counters and base cabinets and are
> debating whether to recycle the Kohler we have now, which is a great
> sink but does require work to keep spotless, or change it out for
> stainless, which I worry will look too rental-unit-ish. I think we'll
> be installing white subway tile on the backsplash wall in front of
> that sink, which ought to look nice. What does the cohort think?

You can't please everyone, you know that. Having said that, I will give you
my answer.

I think porcelain is beautiful. I've had procelain (a double sink) in a
kitchen. When we redid the kitchen counters, we replaced it with stainless
(in 1993.)
Show full article (1.38Kb)
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Wayne Boatwright
Date: Nov 18, 2007 15:40

Oh pshaw, on Sun 18 Nov 2007 03:49:27p, Dee.Dee meant to say...
>
> "KLS" suds.com> wrote in message
> news:73e1k3l6ig00h9uuii1i1go6arq2k444nt@4ax.com...
>> So, which do people think will "sell" a kitchen better: a nice white
>> Kohler porcelain double...
Show full article (1.89Kb)
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: KLS
Date: Nov 18, 2007 16:42

On Sun, 18 Nov 2007 17:49:27 -0500, "Dee.Dee" shentel.net>
wrote:
>
>"KLS" suds.com> wrote in message
>news:73e1k3l6ig00h9uuii1i1go6arq2k444nt@4ax.com...
>> So, which do people think will "sell" a kitchen better: a nice white
>> Kohler porcelain double bowl sink or a stainless steel double bowl
>> sink? We're going to replace the counters and base cabinets and are
>> debating whether to recycle the Kohler we have now, which is a great
>> sink but does require work to keep spotless, or change it out for
>> stainless, which I worry will look too rental-unit-ish. I think we'll
>> be installing white subway tile on the backsplash wall in front of
>> that sink, which ought to look nice. What does the cohort think?

[experiences cut]
>I think it will depend on how up-scale your house now looks.
Show full article (1.18Kb)
1 Comment
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Dee.Dee
Date: Nov 18, 2007 18:30

"KLS" suds.com> wrote in message
news:hsm1k318j7lsddj6siu3v5hihakopn40in@4ax.com...
> On Sun, 18 Nov 2007 17:49:27 -0500, "Dee.Dee" shentel.net>
> wrote:
>
>>
>>"KLS" suds.com> wrote in message
>>news:73e1k3l6ig00h9uuii1i1go6arq2k444nt@4ax.com...
>>> So, which do people think will "sell" a kitchen better: a nice white
>>> Kohler porcelain double bowl sink or a stainless steel double bowl
>>> sink? We're going to replace the counters and base cabinets and are
>>> debating whether to recycle the Kohler we have now, which is a great
>>> sink but does require work to keep spotless, or change it out for
>>> stainless, which I worry will look too rental-unit-ish. I think we'll
>>> be installing white subway tile on the backsplash wall in front of
>>> that sink, which ought to look nice. What does the cohort think?
>
> [experiences cut]
>>I think it will depend on how up-scale your house now looks.
> ...
Show full article (2.00Kb)
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Edwin Pawlowski
Date: Nov 18, 2007 18:55

"Dee.Dee" shentel.net> wrote in message
>
> My thoughts are that the porcelain is great for a 1930's house; it seems
> to fit, and it is definitely a little class IMO.
> But white porcelain for your home -- how can you go wrong?
> Dee Dee

Agree. Aside from some ultra modern industrial looking kitchens, SS does
nothing for me. I'd take a nice white porcelain sink any day and it fits
the style of your home.
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: pltrgyst
Date: Nov 18, 2007 20:53

On Sun, 18 Nov 2007 21:30:02 -0500, "Dee.Dee" shentel.net> wrote:
>And whether this makes sense or not -- there was a time in the 70's
>(perhaps) that everyone was doing porcelain all of a sudden; so porcelain in
>the 70's houses -- maybe because of the different colors available then --
>seem dated to me.

I'm not a fan of white anything, but, as others have said, the white porcelain
fits your house's original style. Stainless fits in anywhere, and was quite
popular throughout the seventies, as well.

And to perhaps combine both the old and the new, you could have your original
white porcelain installed underhung in your new counters, gaining 1.5 inches of
depth along the way, which buyers might appreciate.

But there are also quite a number of colors of porcelain available now, Dee. I
still wouldn't swap my Provence Red porcelain-coated cast iron sink for anything
else. Even SWMBO agrees (a miracle!) 8;)

-- Larry
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Dee.Dee
Date: Nov 19, 2007 19:02

"pltrgyst" spamlessxhost.org> wrote in message
news:ge52k35nqbcrhcp1a9bdq7vdhbt50nda9e@4ax.com...
>
> But there are also quite a number of colors of porcelain available now,
> Dee. I
> still wouldn't swap my Provence Red porcelain-coated cast iron sink for
> anything
> else. Even SWMBO agrees (a miracle!) 8;)
>
> -- Larry

Sorry to barge in here on the porcelain vs. stainless posting, but I guess
it's just time to get this off my chest ;-))
Show full article (3.99Kb)
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Wayne Boatwright
Date: Nov 19, 2007 19:23

Oh pshaw, on Mon 19 Nov 2007 08:02:43p, Dee.Dee meant to say...
>
> "pltrgyst" spamlessxhost.org> wrote in message
> news:ge52k35nqbcrhcp1a9bdq7vdhbt50nda9e@4ax.com...
>
>>
>> But there are also quite a number of colors of porcelain available now,
>> Dee...
Show full article (5.03Kb)
no comments
Re: porcelain vs. stainless         


Author: Dee.Dee
Date: Nov 19, 2007 20:13

"Wayne Boatwright" cox.net> wrote in message >
> I am, indeed, reading this Dee Dee, and I'm glad that things area looking
> up overall, although I handn't realized you had had so many problems. It
> was probably while I was off rfc for a while.
>

I don't think I wrote about the problems -- if I did, it was minimal and
only at first; I took out most of my frustration by documenting all the
stuff that was going on which I patterned after Larry's documentation. One
good thing I did was to take digital pictures; one in particular of a
(about) 10' piece of countertop which they said they were replacing, but
they brought back the very same one. When I showed them that they brought
back the same on --- stutter, stutter stutter; the excuses were flying!
> We moved into our new house last December 20th, and while most things were
> as we expected them, we are still dealing with a few issues that need
> resolution. We have a one year builder's warranty on the home and
> wormanship, so will be turning in a list early next week for work to be
> done.
Show full article (1.33Kb)
no comments
1 2 3