Tap Water VS Bottled Water
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
rec.food.drink.tea only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

rec.food.drink.tea Profile…
 Up
Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Stevepppp
Date: Aug 8, 2008 12:40

What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
floride. And is it true a simple UV light will kill 99.9%% of bacteria
in a gallon of water? TIA.
91 Comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Dominic T.
Date: Aug 8, 2008 13:15

On Aug 8, 3:40 pm, Stevep...@gmail.com wrote:
> What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
> bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
> floride. And is it true a simple UV light will kill 99.9%% of bacteria
> in a gallon of water? TIA.

I would highly doubt you have "high counts" of bacteria in your tap
water as it is treated for just this reason. Fluoride, yes, bacteria,
most likely not. The "cleanest" bottled water is distilled, but that
is not necessarily the best for tea.

Almost all bottled water comes from those very same taps you find
troublesome just around the country. They filter the water and bottle
it. You can do the very same.

I am a hiker and deal with water purification in the field at times, I
prefer either boiling or a chemical (bleach/Aquasafe tablets) to UV
methods like a Steripen. Many use the UV methods but it is not
something I put any trust in.

- Dominic
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: SN
Date: Aug 8, 2008 13:40

bacteria is everywhere in nature
bacteria is all over in/on the human body, contributing to some
essential functions.

from what water report did you read "high count of bacteria" ?

here? http://www.calwater.com/your_water/ccr/pdfs/2007/index.php

if such levels reach a threshold they would stop pumping it as opposed
to giving thousands of people and children diarrhea... and having to
pay 10s of millions of dollars in health care and lawsuits.
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: bookburn
Date: Aug 8, 2008 14:06

On Fri, 8 Aug 2008 12:40:40 -0700 (PDT), Stevepppp@gmail.com wrote:
>What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
>bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
>floride. And is it true a simple UV light will kill 99.9%% of bacteria
>in a gallon of water? TIA.

I saw a UV light, SteriPENN, that fits in a pocket and will kill even
viruses. It's at

http://www.rei.com/product/761905

Problem is, though, the water has to be clear or any particulates,
such as tea, will cause "shadowing" that prevents the UV from working.

bookburn
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Lewis Perin
Date: Aug 8, 2008 14:06

Stevepppp@gmail.com writes:
> What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
> bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
> floride.

If you're worried about fluoride, maybe you shouldn't drink tea, which
adds fluoride to the water it's steeped in.

/Lew
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Dominic T.
Date: Aug 8, 2008 14:26

On Aug 8, 5:06 pm, bookb...@yahoo.com wrote:
> I saw a UV light, SteriPENN, that fits in a pocket and will kill even
> viruses. It's at
>
> http://www.rei.com/product/761905
>
> Problem is, though, the water has to be clear or any particulates,
> such as tea, will cause "shadowing" that prevents the UV from working.
>
> bookburn

I mentioned this device in my reply, however as I briefly stated above
I would never actually trust this in real life as a well seasoned
hiker/backpacker/camper. This reply is not so much directed to you,
but just in general since I didn't expand too much on my distrust of
UV sterilization.
Show full article (1.80Kb)
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Stevepppp
Date: Aug 9, 2008 23:10

On Aug 8, 1:15 pm, "Dominic T." gmail.com> wrote:
> On Aug 8, 3:40 pm, Stevep...@gmail.com wrote:
>
>> What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
>> bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
>> floride. And is it true a simple UV light will kill 99.9%% of bacteria
>> in a gallon of water? TIA.
>
> I would highly doubt you have "high counts" of bacteria in your tap
> water as it is treated for just this reason. Fluoride, yes, bacteria,
> most likely not. The "cleanest" bottled water is distilled, but that
> is not necessarily the best for tea.
>
> Almost all bottled water comes from those very same taps you find
> troublesome just around the country. They filter the water and bottle
> it. You can do the very same.
>
> I am a hiker and deal with water purification in the field at times, I
> prefer either boiling or a chemical (bleach/Aquasafe tablets) to UV
> methods like a Steripen. Many use the UV methods but it is not ...
Show full article (1.20Kb)
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Stevepppp
Date: Aug 9, 2008 23:13

On Aug 8, 1:40 pm, SN gmail.com> wrote:
> bacteria is everywhere in nature
> bacteria is all over in/on the human body, contributing to some
> essential functions.
>
> from what water report did you read "high count of bacteria" ?
>
> here?http://www.calwater.com/your_water/ccr/pdfs/2007/index.php

wow lots of spanish tap drinkers.
No I tested it myself using a kit.
>
> if such levels reach a threshold they would stop pumping it as opposed
> to giving thousands of people and children diarrhea... and having to
> pay 10s of millions of dollars in health care and lawsuits.

It's high, I haven't the figures in front of me. Don't know if it's
high enough to create serious health probs, but long term it may
accumulate enough to be a serious issue.
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Stevepppp
Date: Aug 9, 2008 23:15

On Aug 8, 2:06 pm, bookb...@yahoo.com wrote:
> On Fri, 8 Aug 2008 12:40:40 -0700 (PDT), Stevep...@gmail.com wrote:
>>What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
>>bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
>>floride. And is it true a simple UV light will kill 99.9%% of bacteria
>>in a gallon of water? TIA.
>
> I saw a UV light, SteriPENN,  that fits in a pocket and will kill even
> viruses.  It's at
>
>  http://www.rei.com/product/761905
>
> Problem is, though, the water has to be clear or any particulates,
> such as tea, will cause "shadowing" that prevents the UV from working.
>
> bookburn

Super thanks. Lol. Luckily my tap water isn't as mirky as tea,
especially in the filtered reservoir.
no comments
Re: Tap Water VS Bottled Water         


Author: Stevepppp
Date: Aug 9, 2008 23:19

On Aug 8, 2:06 pm, Lewis Perin panix.com> wrote:
> Stevep...@gmail.com writes:
>> What's the cleanest (from the harmful crap like bacteria/lead/etc)
>> bottled water anyone? Bay area tap water has high counts of bacteria &
>> floride.
>
> If you're worried about fluoride, maybe you shouldn't drink tea, which
> adds fluoride to the water it's steeped in.
>
I drink tea daily for the health benefits. I've read a lot of negative
things about tea. Don't know what to believe anymore without testing
things yourself. That's why it's wise to do it yourself. How adverse
is flouride?
no comments

RELATED THREADS
SubjectArticles qty Group
Whale mixer tap tap problem.uk.rec.caravanning ·
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9