Author: Yeechang LeeYeechang Lee
Date: Jul 17, 2008 13:58
Ken Arromdee wrote:
> Does anyone else watch Doctor Who and think that some of the way
> it's been written resembles V4 LSH, in that you have fans
> controlling the plots, retconning things in, putting in fan theories
> and writing Mary Sues, etc.?
I don't watch Doctor Who. However, as evinced by recent posts, I've
been lately thinking about the larger idea you raise, of how different
writers approach the work and the stylistic tools they use.
Retcons are an obvious and quantifiable example. Levitz's two runs on
the Legion totaled, what, eight or nine years, or about double that of
TMK's. Other than the (supremely elegant) Validus origin and Supergirl
as Brainy's motivation for time travel, I can't offhand think of a
single retcon from the Levitz years. Period. I'm sure other will now
respond with a half-dozen instances I'm forgetting, but my point would
still stand: Levitz certainly did not regularly use them as plot
points, and--with one major, involuntary exception--never as major
ones). Look at the major story arcs of his second run:
|