Re: BACKSCATTERER problem... We are an ISP         


Author: Parthe
Date: Jan 31, 2008 05:26

On Jan 29, 6:56 pm, bon...@host122.r-bonomi.com (Robert Bonomi) wrote:
> In article <797c6e92-da32-469e-b618-cd0365a96...@v17g2000hsa.googlegroups.com>,
>
> Parthe gmail.com> wrote:
>>Whilst I fully appreciate the issues that backscatterer.org and other
>>RBLs have, what can ISPs like my company do? You won't delist us but
>>we don't control our customers mail servers.
>
>>I do my best to monitor the traffic that is pushed through my mail
>>servers, I can and do restrict the customers that spam the network but
>>by the time I do this the backscatter/spam is already forwarded and my
>>company's IP address is blacklisted, in this case for the next 28
>>days.
>
>>How do you justify this?
>
> One justification is "your best is not good enough for {whomever}"
>
> You are entitled to your opinion as to what is acceptable/appropriate effort.
>
> THEY are _equaly_ entitled to their opinion.

Since you speak in the third person I presume you are not a
representative of backscatterers.org.
> end of story.

No, not "end of story", why must you deal in absolutes? I asked their
opinion with the possibility (not guarantee) of coming to a mutually
agreeable solution.

It strikes me (from an ISP point of view, naturally) that maybe ISPs
could be given 24 hours to throttle the offending customer? If the
data given to BS were passed on to me for example I could then deal
with the problem at source and not affect the thousands of other
customers that we have. This would be in BS's favour since my Help
Desk would not be giving them any bad press ("I am sorry you are
having problems sending emails to this email address but they are
refusing it due to backscatterers.org blocking us. They are blocking
us because of one customer that has already been dealt with, but won't
release the block. Sorry sir."). Do you think the customer who phoned
in will have a good opinion of BS or not?

I'm not saying this is the best solution by any means, but it is
certainly one possibility.

|\/|

--
Comments posted to news.admin.net-abuse.blocklisting
are solely the responsibility of their author. Please
read the news.admin.net-abuse.blocklisting FAQ at
http://www.blocklisting.com/faq.html before posting.
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!

RELATED THREADS
SubjectArticles qty Group
cvs commit: src/sys/dev/isp isp.c isp_freebsd.c ispmbox.hmailing.freebsd.cvs ·