10Gb Ethernet on Intel Mac, Myricom 10Gb Eth vs. Cisco Catalyst 3560E X2 CX4/MMF
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
comp.dcom.lans.ethernet only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

comp.dcom.lans.ethernet Profile…
 Up
10Gb Ethernet on Intel Mac, Myricom 10Gb Eth vs. Cisco Catalyst 3560E X2 CX4/MMF         


Author: Frantisek.Rysanek
Date: Jul 23, 2008 00:28

Dear Everyone,

I'd appreciate any practical notes/recommendation/warnings on the
following combination of hardware (and operating system drivers):

We're eyeing some 10Gb Eth adapter cards to be used in MacOS X on an
Intel Mac. The two brands that seem to have drivers for the MacOS are
Intel (3rd-party driver by Small Tree) and Myricom (own driver). We're
planning to attach that to an existing Cisco Catalyst 3560-E series
switch, via the X2 modules available from cisco: either metallic CX4
or the short-range 850nm multimode fibre.

Two questions:

1) do you have any experience with Myricom 10Gb against Cisco Catalyst
switches ? (I assume Intel would work like a charm, the brand size of
Intel and Cisco and the public PR claims of love between the two
brands just make me believe so) Any specific notes regarding the Cisco
and Myricom CX4 metallic and SFP+ vs. X2 multimode optical transceiver
compatibility?

2) do you have any notes regarding Intel+SmallTree or Myricom 10Gb
Ethernet boards under MacOS on Intel Mac? Driver issues, performance,
general compatibility...
Show full article (1.20Kb)
2 Comments
Re: 10Gb Ethernet on Intel Mac, Myricom 10Gb Eth vs. Cisco Catalyst 3560E X2 CX4/MMF         


Author: Patrick Klos
Date: Jul 23, 2008 10:03

In article m44g2000hsc.googlegroups.com>,
wrote:
>Dear Everyone,
>
>I'd appreciate any practical notes/recommendation/warnings on the
>following combination of hardware (and operating system drivers):
>
>We're eyeing some 10Gb Eth adapter cards to be used in MacOS X on an
>Intel Mac. The two brands that seem to have drivers for the MacOS are
>Intel (3rd-party driver by Small Tree) and Myricom (own driver). We're
>planning to attach that to an existing Cisco Catalyst 3560-E series
>switch, via the X2 modules available from cisco: either metallic CX4
>or the short-range 850nm multimode fibre.
>
>Two questions:
>
>1) do you have any experience with Myricom 10Gb against Cisco Catalyst
>switches ? (I assume Intel would work like a charm, the brand size of
>Intel and Cisco and the public PR claims of love between the two
>brands just make me believe so) Any specific notes regarding the Cisco ...
Show full article (2.46Kb)
no comments
Re: 10Gb Ethernet on Intel Mac, Myricom 10Gb Eth vs. Cisco Catalyst 3560E X2 CX4/MMF         


Author: Frantisek.Rysanek
Date: Jul 23, 2008 14:23

On 23 ÄŒec, 19:03, pk...@osmium.mv.net (Patrick Klos) wrote:
> I don't know what the Myricom cards are priced at, but I have to believe
> that the Intel cards due for a price drop based on the looming competition
> from other 10Gbps vendors?? (Maybe it's just wishful thinking?)
>
hmm, the Myricom boards seem to be significantly cheaper than Intel,
let alone Intel with the Mac driver :-)

Thanks at least for the positive reference regarding the Broadcom-
based switch.
So far I haven't gathered too many relevant references, so maybe we'll
just have to take the risk :-)
> Patrick
> ========= For LAN/WAN Protocol Analysis, check out PacketView Pro! =========
> Patrick Klos Email: patr...@klos.com
> Klos Technologies, Inc. ...
Show full article (1.61Kb)
no comments