2-17 The Execution --- A Critique
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.tv.xena only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.tv.xena Profile…
 Up
2-17 The Execution --- A Critique         


Author: David E. Milligan
Date: Jan 28, 2007 13:21

2-17 The Execution

First air date was April 17, 1997.

We start out with Xena and Gabrielle entering a village talking
about a note Meleager sent to Gabrielle about needing them to come. People
are running to go to court. Several men exit a tavern and when Xena tells
them she's a friend of Meleager, they attack and she and Gabrielle have to
fight them off. On a hunch, Xena goes to the courtroom an finds that
Meleager has been found guilty of cold blooded murder.

Gabrielle tries defending him without hearing the testimony
against him, but Judge Arbus has already condemned him to hang when all the
sand in a glass bowl falls through a narrow opening into another one. Xena
says she's heard that he is a fair judge.

In prison, Meleager tells Gabrielle he is innocent, and he was
with a one-eyed man when the murder was committed.

Xena talks to Arbus about the trial, and a woman tells them that
she saw the man die and Meleager ran away with the bloody sword.

Gabrielle insists Meleager is innocent but Xena has her doubts.
Show full article (4.99Kb)
3 Comments
Re: 2-17 The Execution --- A Critique         


Author: poker88
Date: Jan 29, 2007 14:23

On Jan 28, 4:21 pm, "David E. Milligan" bellsouth.net>
wrote:
> *I liked -
>
> that Gabrielle stood up to Xena about believing that Meleager was innocent.
> But I was afraid that she would be proved wrong (I didn't remember that much
> about this episode, including the ending). It seems to me that as the
> seasons progress, Gabrielle is blamed for a lot of things (rightly or not) -
> death of Solan, killing (the prince?) in a sandstorm, and a few others.

I agree with pretty much all of your points on this ep. I especially
liked it when Gabrielle stood up to Xena. I really liked the episodes
where they don't agree on things and there's some tension between
them. I think it makes their relationship a lot more interesting and
gives it more depth. For that reason alone I'm giving this one a 7 of
10.
no comments
Re: 2-17 The Execution --- A Critique         


Author: Ahroo
Date: Jan 29, 2007 14:42

> We start out with Xena and Gabrielle entering a village talking
> about a note Meleager sent to Gabrielle about needing them to come.

Once again, how in the world do all of these messages find their way to X
and G so quickly and easily????
> Xena talks to Arbus about the trial, and a woman tells them that
> she saw the man die and Meleager ran away with the bloody sword.

I really enjoyed that character - an homage to Madame Defarge from a Tale of
Two Cities!
> When Xena sees the sword she says it was her, not Meleager, who killed the
> man. She fought him as he was attacking another man. She goes after the
> man who is hiding where she told him to. She finds him and is taking him
> back, but when he sees they are going to the town he says Arbus is after
> him because he (the man) knows that Arbus executed an innocent man. He
> runs away.
Show full article (2.31Kb)
1 Comment
Re: 2-17 The Execution --- A Critique         


Author: David E. Milligan
Date: Jan 29, 2007 18:26

"Ahroo" hotmail.remove.com> wrote in message
news:2Luvh.5256$O02.4740@newssvr11.news.prodigy.net...
>> We start out with Xena and Gabrielle entering a village talking
>> about a note Meleager sent to Gabrielle about needing them to come.
>
> Once again, how in the world do all of these messages find their way to X
> and G so quickly and easily????
>
>> Xena talks to Arbus about the trial, and a woman tells them that
>> she saw the man die and Meleager ran away with the bloody sword.
>
> I really enjoyed that character - an homage to Madame Defarge from a Tale
> of Two Cities!
>
>> When Xena sees the sword she says it was her, not Meleager, who killed
>> the man. She fought him as he was attacking another man. She goes after
>> the man who is hiding where she told him to. She finds him and is taking
>> him back, but when he sees they are going to the town he says Arbus is
>> after him because he (the man) knows that Arbus executed an innocent man.
>> He runs away. ...
Show full article (2.98Kb)
no comments