Re: "The Ultimate Computer/Remastered" Airs This Weekend
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.startrek only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: "The Ultimate Computer/Remastered" Airs This Weekend         

Group: alt.startrek · Group Profile
Author: GeneK
Date: Feb 9, 2008 17:15

"Jaxtraw" knickersjaxtrawstudios.com> wrote...
> I haven't seen all the remastered episodes, so haven't seen any of the ones
> where the new fx contradict the dialogue, can you give an example?

The two that come most immediately to mind:

The opening of "Space Seed." Originally, the Enterprise
comes up alongside the drifting Botany Bay, which doesn't
do much of anything (because, of course, it's drifting). In
the remastered version, we see the Botany Bay drifting at
an angle suddenly turn itself into alignment with the E as it
approaches. Then, after the opening credits, we get Kirk's
log entry stating that an hour has gone by and their presence
has been *completely ignored,* and *after* some additional
discussion Kirk finally orders a tractor beam on the BB.

The second is "Paradise Syndrome," where the natives
talk about how the medicine chief is supposed to know
how to make "the blue flame" come out of the obelisk.
When Kirk and Spock finally make the obelisk work, the
remastered flame is orange.

These are minor nits, to be sure, but they make one wonder
if the FX team actually listened to the dialog or read a script
before they went to work.
> On the other hand, they've in some cases fixed situations where the original
> effects flatly contradicted the dialogue and script and put new effects in
> that make narrative sense, e.g. in The Doomsday Machine, which is quite a
> bonus I think.

The new FX for DDM made the E seem a bit too jetfighter-
like for my taste, but I could have lived with it if the ship
hadn't looked so much like the one in the old "Star Trek
25th Anniversary" computer game.

GeneK
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!