Author: DrCrawdadDrCrawdad
Date: Dec 30, 2006 16:54
Jeff Dieterle wrote:
> I agree about McCarthy except for the stretch at the tail end of 05 when he
> was put in the rotation, shutdown Cleveland and stopped a slide the for all
> appearances that looked like Cleveland would steamroll us to a wildcard slot
> at best. His reputation had been living off that success probably far too
> long. Hell he didn't even make the 05 playoff roster, and if he would have
> we drop Hernandez, there is no way he could have done what El Duque did to
> Boston. It's hard for me not to trust KW and his staff when it comes to
> judging pitching.
KW has made his mistakes trading for pitchers (see Todd Ritchie). And
the Ritchie trade was bad, even though neither Kip Wells nor Josh Fogg
has done all that much. The point being on that trade though is that
KW should have got something much better than Ritchie.
I find all the comments about this McCarthy trade interesting. Let's
see if in a year or two if a certain Cubbie troll posts here twisting
the comments Sox fans have made here about McCarthy, as the troll did
about Sox fans comments about Wells.
>>
>> "DrCrawdad" gmail.com> wrote in message
>> news:1167487054.927433...
|