Ye Postmodernists
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Ye Postmodernists         


Author: knucmo
Date: Mar 14, 2008 07:57

I have often heard from followers of Wittgenstein and other
fashionable postmodernists that when we say something to be true, all
we are really saying that something is true for one particular
community.

Us Westerners, generally tend to use the word 'true' to say that a
statement about the world accurately and correctly describes the
world: So:

S1. 'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008' is true if and
only if Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008.

The people I speak of in the first paragraph might modify this to:

S2. 'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008' is true for the
Eurocentric Westerners community if and only if (IFF) Knucmo posted on
Usenet on 14th of March 2008.

This implies:

S3. Members of the Eurocentric Westerners community believe that
'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008'.

Suppose though, that:

S4. No members of the Eurocentric Westerners community believe that
'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008'.
Show full article (1.65Kb)
4 Comments
Re: Ye Postmodernists         


Date: Mar 14, 2008 08:56

knucmo wrote:
> I have often heard from followers of Wittgenstein and other
> fashionable postmodernists that when we say something to be true,
> all we are really saying that something is true for one particular
> community.

Can these followers of W support their claim with a quote?
no comments
Re: Ye Postmodernists         


Author: tg
Date: Mar 14, 2008 09:54

On Mar 14, 10:57 am, knucmo 433234.co.uk> wrote:
> I have often heard from followers of Wittgenstein and other
> fashionable postmodernists that when we say something to be true, all
> we are really saying that something is true for one particular
> community.  
>
> Us Westerners, generally tend to use the word 'true' to say that a
> statement about the world accurately and correctly describes the
> world: So:
>
> S1. 'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008' is true if and
> only if Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008.
>
> The people I speak of

Are they travelling in the company of a small dog, a young girl, a
lion, and a metallic humanoid?

-tg
> in the first paragraph might modify this to:
>
> S2. 'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008' is true for the
> Eurocentric Westerners community if and only if (IFF) Knucmo posted on
> Usenet...
Show full article (1.91Kb)
no comments
Re: Ye Postmodernists         


Author: knucmo
Date: Mar 14, 2008 13:36

On Fri, 14 Mar 2008 09:54:42 -0700 (PDT), tg earthlink.net>
wrote:
>On Mar 14, 10:57 am, knucmo 433234.co.uk> wrote:
>> I have often heard from followers of Wittgenstein and other
>> fashionable postmodernists that when we say something to be true, all
>> we are really saying that something is true for one particular
>> community.  
>>
>> Us Westerners, generally tend to use the word 'true' to say that a
>> statement about the world accurately and correctly describes the
>> world: So:
>>
>> S1. 'Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008' is true if and
>> only if Knucmo posted on Usenet on 14th of March 2008.
>>
>> The people I speak of
>
>Are they travelling in the company of a small dog, a young girl, a
>lion, and a metallic humanoid?
Show full article (0.87Kb)
no comments
Re: Ye Postmodernists         


Author: Sean
Date: Mar 14, 2008 17:11

According to my information, you posted on the 15th March 2008.

So, you must be a LIAR LIAR ..... [ sorry, just wanted to sound like
Christopher from alt.atheism for a moment ]

It's amazing what a difference a Date line can make. Which again goes to
show that like everything else, truth depends primarily on your point of
view.

THEREFORE change your point of view, and the world changes before your eyes.

THAT's the Truth! :)

--
"We look at everything in terms of American culture, and how Americans see
the world, not how other people and it's a failing which hurts us."
Former US Naval officer Dr Harlan Ullman 3/12/2008

"knucmo" 433234.co.uk> wrote in message
news:lc3lt3dtsn9delq1hrpv0ve02mnsi6i5fm@4ax.com...
>I have often heard from followers of Wittgenstein and other
> fashionable postmodernists that when...
Show full article (2.48Kb)
no comments