> On Aug 13, 8:15 am, "Spaceman"
> wrote:

>> Timberwoof wrote:

>>> In article comcast.com>,
>>> "Spaceman" wrote:

>>

>>>> Timberwoof wrote:

>>>>> In article comcast.com>,
>>>>> "Spaceman" wrote:

>>

>>>>>> Timberwoof wrote:

>>>>>>> In article comcast.com>,
>>>>>>> "Spaceman" wrote:

>>

>>>>>>>> Sanny wrote:

>>>>>>>>> Why do Scientist say Universe is expanding?

>>

>>>>>>>> Because they forget that light take time to travel
>>>>>>>> and every year, we will see anopther years light hit us.
>>>>>>>> It is not physically expanding, we are just seeing more
>>>>>>>> each year since it takes that long for us to see more.

>>

>>>>>>> I'm pretty sure that some bright clever university student has
>>>>>>> already thought of this.

>>

>>>>>>>>> What is the rate of Expansion?

>>

>>>>>>>> 0 physical expansion
>>>>>>>> 1 year more distance seen per year we are looking.

>>

>>>>>>> You forget the Hubble Constant and the redshift of galaxies.

>>

>>>>>> So explain why Andromeda is ignoring such then?

>>

>>>>> There are two sets of motions going on. On the small scale -- and
>>>>> compared to the universe, the distance to Andromeda is tiny --
>>>>> galaxies move around and collide with each other. Many
>>>>> gravitationally bound groups of galaxies exist; astronomers see
>>>>> them everywhere.

>>

>>>>> The second set is the expansion of the universe, which is carrying
>>>>> clusters of galaxies with it.

>>

>>>> So where are we all heading outward too?

>>

>>> The universe has an interesting property: anisotropy. The expansion
>>> looks the same *everywhere*. Anywhere you are, everything else is
>>> moving away.

>>
>> Then you must figure out one problem then,
>> Where is it all expanding from and what causes the "creation" of
>> space outside where it is expanding to?
>> Do you have magical point particle big bangs occuring still at the
>> "supposed edges" making "new space" so it can expand?
>> You truly need to wake up a bit.
>> If everything is moving away, It needs space already there to move
>> away at all.
>> Try using some logic some time.
>> Sheesh man!
>>
>> --
>> James M Driscoll Jr
>> Creator of the Clock Malfunction Theory
>> Spaceman

>
>
> I never cease to be amazed by your inscrutable logic, Spaceman!