Re: Why be Jewish?
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: pjmutnick
Date: Dec 4, 2007 13:46

On Dec 4, 1:23 pm, pjmutn...@sbcglobal.net wrote:
> On Dec 4, 11:55 am, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
>>> Scholem, from Major Trends of Jewish Mysticism, p. 125:
>
>>> Generally speaking, lay mystics - self-taught and untutored by
>>> Rabbinism - have always been a potential source of heretical thought.
>>> Jewish mysticism tried to meet this danger by stipulating in principle
>>> that entry into the domain of mystical thought and practice should be
>>> reserved to rabbinic scholars. In actual fact, however, there has
>>> been no lack of Kabbalists who either had learning whatsoever, or who
>>> lacked the proper rabbinic training. Thus enabled to look at Judaism
>>> from a fresh angle, these men frequently produced highly important and
>>> interesting ideas, and so there grew up, side by side with the
>>> scholarly Kabbalah of the Rabbis, another line of prophetic and
>>> visionary mystics. The pristine enthusiasm of these early ecstatics ...
Show full article (3.99Kb)
270 Comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: cactus
Date: Dec 4, 2007 14:49

pjmutnick@sbcglobal.net wrote:
> On Dec 4, 1:23 pm, pjmutn...@sbcglobal.net wrote:
>> On Dec 4, 11:55 am, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>>> Scholem, from Major Trends of Jewish Mysticism, p. 125:
>>>> Generally speaking, lay mystics - self-taught and untutored by
>>>> Rabbinism - have always been a potential source of heretical thought.
>>>> Jewish mysticism tried to meet this danger by stipulating in principle
>>>> that entry into the domain of mystical thought and practice should be
>>>> reserved to rabbinic scholars. In actual fact, however, there has
>>>> been no lack of Kabbalists who either had learning whatsoever, or who
>>>> lacked the proper rabbinic training. Thus enabled to look at Judaism
>>>> from a fresh angle, these men frequently produced highly important and
>>>> interesting ideas, and so there grew up, side by side with the
>>>> scholarly Kabbalah of the Rabbis, another line of prophetic and
>>>> visionary mystics. The pristine enthusiasm of these early ecstatics ...
Show full article (4.65Kb)
39 Comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: pjmutnick
Date: Dec 4, 2007 15:01

On Dec 4, 2:49 pm, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
> pjmutn...@sbcglobal.net wrote:
>> On Dec 4, 1:23 pm, pjmutn...@sbcglobal.net wrote:
>>> On Dec 4, 11:55 am, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>
>>>>> Scholem, from Major Trends of Jewish Mysticism, p. 125:
>>>>> Generally speaking, lay mystics - self-taught and untutored by
>>>>> Rabbinism - have always been a potential source of heretical thought.
>>>>> Jewish mysticism tried to meet this danger by stipulating in principle
>>>>> that entry into the domain of mystical thought and practice should be
>>>>> reserved to rabbinic scholars. In actual fact, however, there has
>>>>> been no lack of Kabbalists who either had learning whatsoever, or who
>>>>> lacked the proper rabbinic training. Thus enabled to look at Judaism
>>>>> from a fresh angle, these men frequently produced highly important and
>>>>> interesting ideas, and so there grew up, side by side with the
>>>>> scholarly Kabbalah of the Rabbis, another line of prophetic and
>>>>> visionary mystics. The pristine enthusiasm of these early ecstatics
>>>>> frequently lifted the heavy lid of rabbinic scholasticism....
>>>>> Kabbalah (Meridian) (Paperback)
>>>>> by Gershon Scholem (Author) "Kabbalah" is the traditional and most ...
Show full article (5.72Kb)
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: MichaelNJ
Date: Dec 4, 2007 15:02

On Dec 4, 5:49 pm, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
> pjmutn...@sbcglobal.net wrote:
>> On Dec 4, 1:23 pm, pjmutn...@sbcglobal.net wrote:
>>> On Dec 4, 11:55 am, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>
>>>>> Scholem, from Major Trends of Jewish Mysticism, p. 125:
>>>>> Generally speaking, lay mystics - self-taught and untutored by
>>>>> Rabbinism - have always been a potential source of heretical thought.
>>>>> Jewish mysticism tried to meet this danger by stipulating in principle
>>>>> that entry into the domain of mystical thought and practice should be
>>>>> reserved to rabbinic scholars. In actual fact, however, there has
>>>>> been no lack of Kabbalists who either had learning whatsoever, or who
>>>>> lacked the proper rabbinic training. Thus enabled to look at Judaism
>>>>> from a fresh angle, these men frequently produced highly important and
>>>>> interesting ideas, and so there grew up, side by side with the
>>>>> scholarly Kabbalah of the Rabbis, another line of prophetic and
>>>>> visionary mystics. The pristine enthusiasm of these early ecstatics
>>>>> frequently lifted the heavy lid of rabbinic scholasticism....
>>>>> Kabbalah (Meridian) (Paperback)
>>>>> by Gershon Scholem (Author) "Kabbalah" is the traditional and most ...
Show full article (5.27Kb)
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: THE BORG
Date: Dec 5, 2007 07:25

gmail.com> wrote in message
news:6b617416-0950-42d8-b608-beadf44a3eb5@i12g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
> Mankind (not Jews in particular) were told they needed and would get a
> Messiah. Abram was told that the Messiah would come through his line
> and that his descendents (through Issac) would be set apart. God
> formed a special pact with Abraham - and through him to all Jews. My
> understanding is that most Jews and Christians believe this.
> Christians believe that Jesus was the fullfillment of those promises.
Show full article (2.59Kb)
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: THE BORG
Date: Dec 5, 2007 08:06

sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
news:d3990da5-a318-4df0-a2da-5caae19311f3@e6g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
> Hey, you damn machine, what do you know about humans?
>
We have learnt much about you - we video and record all our experiences.
Humans are most interesting subject.
Regards
THE BORG
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: pjmutnick
Date: Dec 5, 2007 08:17

On Dec 5, 8:06 am, "THE BORG" outthere.com> wrote:
> sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
>
> news:d3990da5-a318-4df0-a2da-5caae19311f3@e6g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
>
>> Hey, you damn machine, what do you know about humans?
>
> We have learnt much about you - we video and record all our experiences.
> Humans are most interesting subject.
> Regards
> THE BORG

I am afraid you haven't learned much. Thinking that Jews are special
only sows the seeds of inequality and hatred on planet earth. All men
are equal.
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: flaviaR
Date: Dec 5, 2007 14:13

On 5-Dec-2007, "cindys" rochester.rr.com> wrote:
> sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
> news:ab39945a-7574-4377-999a-2d0539868c05@d4g2000prg.googlegroups.com...
>> On Dec 5, 9:59 am, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>>> jjs wrote:
>>> ...
Show full article (1.81Kb)
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: flaviaR
Date: Dec 5, 2007 20:25

On 5-Dec-2007, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>> The death penalty is a very humbling point. Does that mean that a devout
>> Jew
>> would vote against a pro-capital punishment law? (I realize it is not a
>> voted issue.)
>
> Presumably. However, as the saying goes, "Two Jews, three opinions."

The real problkem is thatthe Jewish stance on the death penalty
can really only come into play ina Torah-ruled land. When Jews
do not live in such a place, they know the laws of the civil authority
must hold sway.

I freely admit to not wanting to have to put up with the Torah-
mandated death penalty because it is laughingly lenient. You
have to have 2 competant witnesses to even get someone
convicted, &, even then, the rabbis might decide that such a
person is obviously mentally ill to have done such a thing, & is
therefore not liable to be put to death.
Show full article (1.03Kb)
no comments
Re: Why be Jewish?         


Author: pjmutnick
Date: Dec 6, 2007 06:53

On Dec 5, 8:25 pm, flav...@verizon.net wrote:
> On 5-Dec-2007, cactus nonespam.com> wrote:
>
>>> The death penalty is a very humbling point. Does that mean that a devout
>>> Jew
>>> would vote against a pro-capital punishment law? (I realize it is not a
>>> voted issue.)
>
>> Presumably. However, as the saying goes, "Two Jews, three opinions."

Our experience on this forum is a hundred Jews, one opinion. No
originality of thought, no thought at all, just well-programmed
"opinions."
2 Comments
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9