were benjamin and macluhan right in the end?
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
were benjamin and macluhan right in the end?         


Author: sirblob2
Date: Aug 19, 2008 20:12

peer to peer established a new era and a new viewing experience.
everyone just downloaded entire seasons in 2 hours. everyone just
downloaded, like painters in the modern city, like baudelaire. so
technological determinism was where it was at all the time?
4 Comments
Re: were benjamin and macluhan right in the end?         


Author: neo-anchorite
Date: Aug 20, 2008 04:02

On Aug 20, 6:12 am, sirbl...@hotmail.com wrote:
> peer to peer established a new era and a new viewing experience.
> everyone just downloaded entire seasons in 2 hours. everyone just
> downloaded, like painters in the modern city, like baudelaire. so
> technological determinism was where it was at all the time?
no comments
Re: were benjamin and macluhan right in the end?         


Author: neo-anchorite
Date: Aug 20, 2008 04:04

Interesting, but say more. What did Baudelaire download?

Of course, McLuhan was right that people become appendages of
machines, but how does Limewire mark something very different from
that already marked TVs constitution of consciousness as flotsam?

http://tornhalves.wordpress.com
no comments
Re: were benjamin and macluhan right in the end?         


Author: sirblob2
Date: Aug 21, 2008 12:59

On 20 ago, 13:04, neo-anchorite wrote:
> Interesting, but say more. What did Baudelaire download?
>
> Of course, McLuhan was right that people become appendages of
> machines, but how does Limewire mark something very different from
> that already marked TVs constitution of consciousness as flotsam?
>
> http://tornhalves.wordpress.com

the comparison with baudelaire was excessive.

mcluhan was excessive when he thought difficulty would be needed in
works of art, equating with the avant garde. however, there's the
technological platform to be taken into account from a kantian
misprision that's never been inclined to being in love with mass art.
Show full article (1.31Kb)
no comments
Re: were benjamin and macluhan right in the end?         


Author: neo-anchorite
Date: Aug 22, 2008 01:50

Slow down.

First make the issue clear. Right about what? In relation to which
prior argument? And why does this matter?

Sobriety, although not much fun, does aid communication.
no comments