Study: No gender differences in math performance
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: ganeshchawla6
Date: Jul 28, 2008 05:31

We've all heard it. Some in fact believe it. Girls just aren't as
good at math as boys. But it is not true !

http://www.theanalystmagazine.com/pr/7010710.htm
16 Comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: Bret Cahill
Date: Jul 28, 2008 06:47

> �We've all heard it. Some in fact believe it. Girls just aren't as
> good at math as boys. But it is not true !

Clearly the woman conducting the study can't handle statistics.

: - )

Bret Cahill
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: BretCahill
Date: Aug 17, 2008 11:38

> �We've all heard it. Some in fact believe it.Girlsjust aren't as
> good atmathas boys. But it is not true !
>
> http://www.theanalystmagazine.com/pr/7010710.htm

I expected a little serious discussion on this issue.

Bret Cahill
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: Dave Dodson
Date: Aug 17, 2008 12:05

On Aug 17, 1:38 pm, BretCah...@peoplepc.com wrote:
>> We've all heard it. Some in fact believe it.Girlsjust aren't as
>> good atmathas boys. But it is not true !
>
>
> I expected a little serious discussion on this issue.

In my opinion, the study doesn't go far enough in age. Here are some
questions that I think would have to be answered to draw the
conclusion that they reach:

1. Which gender has the higher percentage of high school students that
take elective advanced math courses such as precalculus and AP
calculus?

2. If you figured the fraction of men who start a bachelors degree
program in math that finish it, and the fraction of women who start a
bachelors degree program in math that finish it, how do the two
fractions compare?

3. Same question for graduate degrees in math.
Show full article (1.12Kb)
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: Theresa McCarty
Date: Aug 17, 2008 15:49

My "dogma" has been that there is no difference between men and women.
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: BretCahill
Date: Aug 17, 2008 19:28

> My "dogma" has been that there is no difference between men and women.

There definitely is a difference.

The question is if any difference in math ability appears as they age.

If there is maybe it isn't directly traceable to biology, i. e., a
woman can always get a dumb guy to do the math.

Bret Cahill
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: BretCahill
Date: Aug 17, 2008 19:32

>>> We've all heard it. Some in fact believe it.Girlsjust aren't as
>>> good atmathas boys. But it is not true !
>> I expected a little serious discussion on this issue.
> In my opinion, the study doesn't go far enough in age. Here are some
> questions that I think would have to be answered to draw the
> conclusion that they reach:
> 1. Which gender has the higher percentage of high school students that
> take elective advanced math courses such as precalculus and AP
> calculus?
> 2. If you figured the fraction of men who start a bachelors degree
> program in math that finish it, and the fraction of women who start a
> bachelors degree program in math that finish it, how do the two
> fractions compare?
> 3. Same question for graduate degrees in math.
> 4. How many women drop out of math-intensive science curriculums
> because of difficulty with the math courses compared to the number of
> men who drop out for that reason?
Show full article (1.35Kb)
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: Han de Bruijn
Date: Aug 18, 2008 00:11

BretCahill@peoplepc.com wrote:
> For a long time blacks weren't encouraged to play professional
> sports. The conclusion from not having any blacks on pro teams might
> be that blacks weren't any good at sports.

You're kidding. I've always thought black people were rather dominant at
the Olympics, organized by Hitler, Berlin 1936, much to his frustration.
The African-American Jesse Owens was the undisputed hero of the games.

Han de Bruijn
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: Day Brown
Date: Aug 18, 2008 19:53

Theresa McCarty wrote:
> My "dogma" has been that there is no difference between men and women.
>
>
the bell curve for men is spread out more. Yes, more men are geniuses,
but if you worked in clinical settings, you'd know that more men are
also the severe retards and totally whacked out psychotics.

Mother Nature clipped the bell curve for women to ensure they were
competent enuf to nurture children. So, yes more women can handle simple
math, but when it comes to higher math, then you need men, with a kind
of tunnel vision of the mind, to deal with it.

Women are more distracted by the emotional needs of others. Geeks are
not. The most successful enterprise would have women managing the sex
lives of creative geeks to max out their productivity, but not trying to
have monogamous relationships with the geeks cause the geeks are just
not that attentive to emotional needs.
Show full article (1.28Kb)
no comments
Re: Study: No gender differences in math performance         


Author: BretCahill
Date: Aug 18, 2008 20:28

>> For a long time blacks weren't encouraged to play professional
>> sports. The conclusion from not having any blacks on pro teams might
>> be that blacks weren't any good at sports.
>
> You're kidding. I've always thought black people were rather dominant at
> the Olympics, organized by Hitler, Berlin 1936, much to his frustration.
> The African-American Jesse Owens was the undisputed hero of the games.

Maybe something similar is going on with women in math.

It's hard to say because of all fields math must be the least
interested in anything except performance.

There is no reason for anyone to know who your are.

Bret Cahill
no comments
1 2