Re: ...Science Reinvents God... by Stuart Kauffman
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: ...Science Reinvents God... by Stuart Kauffman         

Group: alt.philosophy · Group Profile
Author: Jerry Kraus
Date: Sep 19, 2008 09:00

On Sep 18, 8:46 pm, Day Brown daybrown.org> wrote:
> Jerry Kraus wrote:
>> Sounds like an elaborate rationalization of the simple and obvious
>> fact the scientists, currently, haven't the slightest idea what
>> they're doing.
>
>> How about doing a better job on pragmatic reductionism, solving some
>> real world problems, and not trying to justify scientific incompetence
>> on the basis of a theistic conception of human impotence?
> Sure. Just a sec.
>> You are quite correct that this is not conventional religion.
>> Conventional religion attempts to exalt humanity.  Kauffman's
>> conception degrades it.  To the level of utter incompetence of modern
>> science.
>
> Who getsta decide what degredaton is? There's another example to
> consider dug up by archeology in prehistoric SE Europe. See Gimbutas,
> "The Language of the Goddess", in which she tries to reconstruct the
> original Aryan cosmology. Joseph Campbell wrote the forward, which he
> closes with:"The message here is of an actual age of peace and harmony
> with the creative energies of Nature, which for a spell of some 4000
> prehistoric years anteceded the 5000 of what James Joyce has termed the
> 'nightmare' (of contending tribal and national interests) from which it
> is certainly time for this planet to wake." [his parens]
>
> This claim of a real 'Golden Age of Peace' has been hotly debated in
> archeology. But if you look at the collections of artifacts recovered
> from the tels in the river basins that empty into the west end of the
> Black Sea from 8000-4000 BC, it aint what they found, its what they
> didnt. There are no weapons even tho they invented bronze. There are no
> graves of warriors and no iconography of weapons or warfare.
>
> Goodison and Morris set out to open up a virgin tel specifically looking
>   for signs of warfare, which they report in "Ancient Goddesses" down
> thru 4000 years of occupation layers, they did not find any.
>
> Campbell, Eliade, Gimbutas, and others have collected snippets of myth
> and iconography and collated them using the rules of etymology to
> reconstruct the cosmology. to wit:
> Chaos, not god, was the primordial initial state.
>
> But just as any study of random phenomena will reveal, eventually you
> get something that self replicates. Thus Gaia *evolves* out of Chaos.
>
> And since She continues to evolve, as life still does, eventually She
> reached a state of sentience and differentiated Herself from Chaos to
> produce 'Maya', the physical universe.  And like all natural Mothers,
> has the instinct to create more life, but unlike god, has no divine
> plan, but sets life free to fulfill its own destiny.
>
> The Bible has you here to please god and his host. Gaia has you here
> that She mite please you. The reason for the Golden Age of peace becomes
> more clear when you consider the problem a demagogue would have trying
> to rile up a mob or an army by claiming that *HE* speaks in *HER* name.
>
> The Biblical god relies on the negative re-inforcement of threats of
> damnation and force to compel obedience. Gaia uses the positive
> re-inforcement of sex, drugs, rock and roll. Thus, She is often depicted
> dancing. And now that the brave heart, strong right arm, sword in hand-
> no longer cuts it, the other power of the cunt to get cooperation is
> taking over. There are no systems of safe weapons, but women have
> figured out how to use safe sex.

Well, obviously without cities one can't very well have major wars,
Day. And, you have very little reason to have them. If everyone's
spread out enough, major conflicts are much less likely to arise
between people, and there aren't large population concentrations to
engage in them.

On the other hand, our current "Nightmare" has dramatically increased
human life expectancy. Then again, so did Comrade Stalin, in Russia.
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!