Group: alt.philosophy · Group Profile
Author: WordsmithWordsmith Date: Aug 31, 2008 13:50
On Aug 31, 2:10Â pm, Shrikeb...@ gmail.com wrote:
>>> Hi. What book or books would you recommend on philosophy as a whole? I
>>> mean a kind of textbook, a survey, an introduction. I just don't know a
>>> good one.
>
>> Supposedly _The Republic_ is recommended if you want a one book
>> library. Â Basically Socrates attacks of all the decadent hypocrisy in
>> ancient Athens.
>
> Oh please. Â Basically in _The Republic_ Plato
> equivocates on the definition of the word "justice"
> to make apologies for a Spartan, 1984-with-a-
> happy-face, State. Â Everyone prefers the earlier
> dialogues.
>
>> Later Heller did the same in _Picture This_.
>
> Oh, please. Â Everyone knows that Heller's
> masterpiece is _Catch-22_, after which he
> simply jumped the shark, as the saying goes.
> It's incredible how someone who could write
> Catch-22, which is one of the funniest novels
> of the twentieth century, could only rise to
> the level of the uninspired yawn-fests his
> works since have been. Â The wonder of the
> one-hit wonder.
*Catch 22* was all right, but for some reason
I liked his second novel, *Something Happened* more.
W : )
|