Poland made the correct decision
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Jerry Kraus
Date: Aug 15, 2008 12:49

Poland was correct to agree to placement of the missile defence system
in direct response to the Russian occupation of Georgia. Russia is in
a position to reestablish the Soviet Union. Several of the former
Soviet republics have never really left Russia -- e.g.,Kazakhstan,
Byelorussia -- Russia maintains military forces there and controls the
governments. All of the others have very large Russian populations,
including the Baltic Republics, which are now members of NATO. They
will all go back to Russia. All of them.

But, Poland was not a part of the Soviet Union. The Russians want
them, but, they are a reasonably large, and fiercely independant
nation, without a sizable Russian population. Given support from
NATO, they can hold off the Russians. Historically, Poland has been
defeated when Germany and Russia split the country up, between them.
If the Germans back up Poland, the Russians will not touch her.

The decision by Poland to side unequivocally with NATO in setting up
the missile defence system shows Russia that they will have to risk a
world war. The Russians will not do this over Poland.
58 Comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: John Jones
Date: Aug 15, 2008 13:09

Jerry Kraus wrote:
> Poland was correct to agree to placement of the missile defence system
> in direct response to the Russian occupation of Georgia. Russia is in
> a position to reestablish the Soviet Union. Several of the former
> Soviet republics have never really left Russia -- e.g.,Kazakhstan,
> Byelorussia -- Russia maintains military forces there and controls the
> governments. All of the others have very large Russian populations,
> including the Baltic Republics, which are now members of NATO. They
> will all go back to Russia. All of them.
>
> But, Poland was not a part of the Soviet Union. The Russians want
> them, but, they are a reasonably large, and fiercely independant
> nation, without a sizable Russian population. Given support from
> NATO, they can hold off the Russians. Historically, Poland has been
> defeated when Germany and Russia split the country up, between them.
> If the Germans back up Poland, the Russians will not touch her.
>
> The decision by Poland to side unequivocally with NATO in setting up
> the missile defence system shows Russia that they will have to risk a
> world war. The Russians will not do this over Poland. ...
Show full article (1.83Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Robert Cohen
Date: Aug 15, 2008 13:25

On Aug 15, 3:49 pm, Jerry Kraus yahoo.com> wrote:
> Poland was correct to agree to placement of the missile defence system
> in direct response to the Russian occupation of Georgia.  Russia is in
> a position to reestablish the Soviet Union.  Several of the former
> Soviet republics have never really left Russia -- e.g.,Kazakhstan,
> Byelorussia -- Russia maintains military forces there and controls the
> governments.  All of the others have very large Russian populations,
> including the Baltic Republics, which are now members of NATO.  They
> will all go back to Russia.  All of them.
>
> But, Poland was not a part of the Soviet Union.  The Russians want
> them, but, they are a reasonably large, and fiercely independant
> nation, without a sizable Russian population.  Given support from
> NATO, they can hold off the Russians.  Historically, Poland has been
> defeated when Germany and Russia split the country up, between them.
> If the Germans back up Poland, the Russians will not touch her.
>
> The decision by Poland to side unequivocally with NATO in setting up
> the missile defence system shows Russia that they will have to risk a
> world war.  The Russians will not do this over Poland. ...
Show full article (1.84Kb)
4 Comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: lorad
Date: Aug 15, 2008 13:30

On Aug 15, 1:09 pm, John Jones aol.com> wrote:
> Jerry Kraus wrote:
>> Poland was correct to agree to placement of the missile defence system
>> in direct response to the Russian occupation of Georgia.  Russia is in
>> a position to reestablish the Soviet Union.  Several of the former
>> Soviet republics have never really left Russia -- e.g.,Kazakhstan,
>> Byelorussia -- Russia maintains military forces there and controls the
>> governments.  All of the others have very large Russian populations,
>> including the Baltic Republics, which are now members of NATO.  They
>> will all go back to Russia.  All of them.
>
>> But, Poland was not a part of the Soviet Union.  The Russians want
>> them, but, they are a reasonably large, and fiercely independant
>> nation, without a sizable Russian population.  Given support from
>> NATO, they can hold off the Russians.  Historically, Poland has been
>> defeated when Germany and Russia split the country up, between them.
>> If the Germans back up Poland, the Russians will not touch her.
>
>> The decision by Poland to side unequivocally with NATO in setting up
>> the missile defence system shows Russia that they will have to risk a ...
Show full article (2.24Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Jerry Kraus
Date: Aug 15, 2008 13:34

On Aug 15, 3:25 pm, Robert Cohen msn.com> wrote:
> On Aug 15, 3:49 pm, Jerry Kraus yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
>> Poland was correct to agree to placement of the missile defence system
>> in direct response to the Russian occupation of Georgia.  Russia is in
>> a position to reestablish the Soviet Union.  Several of the former
>> Soviet republics have never really left Russia -- e.g.,Kazakhstan,
>> Byelorussia -- Russia maintains military forces there and controls the
>> governments.  All of the others have very large Russian populations,
>> including the Baltic Republics, which are now members of NATO.  They
>> will all go back to Russia.  All of them.
>
>> But, Poland was not a part of the Soviet Union.  The Russians want
>> them, but, they are a reasonably large, and fiercely independant
>> nation, without a sizable Russian population.  Given support from
>> NATO, they can hold off the Russians.  Historically, Poland has been ...
Show full article (2.39Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Heli
Date: Aug 15, 2008 13:57

In article
<25119625-16bd-47dc-bb71-c91f1768a176@y38g2000hsy.googlegroups.com>,
Jerry Kraus yahoo.com> wrote:
> I stated exactly what will happen. All former Soviet Republics --
> including the Baltics and the Ukraine -- will be reunited with
> Russia. They should never have been seperated. They are all
> Russians...
Show full article (1.35Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Jerry Kraus
Date: Aug 15, 2008 14:26

On Aug 15, 3:57 pm, Heli wrote:
> In article
> <25119625-16bd-47dc-bb71-c91f1768a...@y38g2000hsy.googlegroups.com>,
>
> Jerry Kraus yahoo.com> wrote:
>> I stated exactly what will happen.  All former Soviet Republics --
>> including the Baltics and the Ukraine -- will be reunited with
>> Russia.  They should never have been seperated.  They are all
>> Russians, or largely Russians.  The Russians will not regain control
>> over most of the former satellites however, at least not in the short
>> term.
>
> That's right. The only thing Russia wants is to have safe borders. That
> is exactly what the US will never guarantee, because they want Russia.
> The US almost had Russia in its pocket after Yeltsin squandered the
> Russian oil and gave it away. The West (US and Britain) are mad at
> Russia because Putin tackled the oligarchs and gave the Russian people
> its resources back. The missiles in Poland are aimed at Russia. No
> other state would allow such a thing, certainly not the US. So again
> it's a matter of imposing the will of the most arrogant, in this case ...
Show full article (1.67Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Bret Cahill
Date: Aug 15, 2008 15:01

>>> I stated exactly what will happen.  All former Soviet Republics --
>>> including the Baltics and the Ukraine -- will be reunited with
>>> Russia.  They should never have been seperated.  They are all
>>> Russians, or largely Russians.  The Russians will not regain control
>>> over most of the former satellites however, at least not in the short
>>> term.
>
>> That's right. The only thing Russia wants is to have safe borders. That
>> is exactly what the US will never guarantee, because they want Russia.
>> The US almost had Russia in its pocket after Yeltsin squandered the
>> Russian oil and gave it away. The West (US and Britain) are mad at
>> Russia because Putin tackled the oligarchs and gave the Russian people
>> its resources back. The missiles in Poland are aimed at Russia. No
>> other state would allow such a thing, certainly not the US. So again
>> it's a matter of imposing the will of the most arrogant, in this case
>> the US. The US and Britain consider they have a moral right to the
>> riches of other nations. It's literally written in Brzezinski's book
>> about the American primacy and its geostrategic imperatives. In one
>> word, it's the denial of the sovereignty and right to resources of all
>> other nations. ...
Show full article (1.66Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: Heli
Date: Aug 15, 2008 15:09

In article
<641be6ea-13ac-4f25-99fb-c28f390cb0fa@w24g2000prd.googlegroups.com>,
Bret Cahill aol.com> wrote:
>>>> I stated exactly what will happen.  All former Soviet Republics --
>>>> including the Baltics and the Ukraine -- will be reunited with
>>>> Russia.  They should never have been seperated...
Show full article (2.20Kb)
no comments
Re: Poland made the correct decision         


Author: abelard
Date: Aug 15, 2008 15:52

On Sat, 16 Aug 2008 00:09:31 +0200, Heli
wrote:
>And bombing Vietnam, Iraq, Aghanistan, etc. etc. That's more than
>imposing your will,

why are you dishonestly pretending the above were free countries?

why are you therefore suggesting georgia is somehow an equivalent
case?
>it's having people make their last will.
>It's an industry. You destroy, the taxpayer pays, you 'rebuild' (read
>'rob the resources') with money of the conquered nation.
>Of course, always mention you do it for humanitarian reasons.
Show full article (1.09Kb)
no comments

RELATED THREADS
SubjectArticles qty Group
[email][83.26.164.226 PL AS5617 83.0.0.0/11] Accept the correct decisionnews.admin.netabuse.sightings ·
1 2 3 4 5 6