Knowledge is not Power
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Knowledge is not Power         


Author: ZerkonX
Date: Sep 8, 2008 04:02

Knowledge has no power without action. Ignorance in action has power.
Knowledge alone yields nothing without act.

It is Action or Process that is power not knowledge.
44 Comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: student13
Date: Sep 8, 2008 05:26

But to perform any action, don't you think some knowledge is needed
even if that knowledge turns out to be wrong
knowledge? And depending on the result of action, we come to know
that we had all the right knowledge
needed to perform the action at that time or not?

enjoy
cheers
st13

On Sep 8, 4:02 pm, ZerkonX X.net> wrote:
> Knowledge has no power without action. Ignorance in action has power.
> Knowledge alone yields nothing without act.
>
> It is Action or Process that is power not knowledge.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: Sean
Date: Sep 8, 2008 06:18

"ZerkonX" X.net> wrote in message news:pan.2008.09.08.11.02.40@X.net...
>
> Knowledge has no power without action. Ignorance in action has power.
> Knowledge alone yields nothing without act.
>
> It is Action or Process that is power not knowledge.
>

Can't agree here. Knowledge is power. Action is applied power, for want of a
better way to put it.

Power is power whether applied or not. iow potential power is still power.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: Don Stockbauer
Date: Sep 8, 2008 06:35

On Sep 8, 8:18 am, "Sean" now.com.au> wrote:
> "ZerkonX" X.net> wrote in messagenews:pan.2008.09.08.11.02.40@X.net...
>
>> Knowledge has no power without action. Ignorance in action has power.
>> Knowledge alone yields nothing without act.
>
>> It is Action or Process that is power not knowledge.
>
> Can't agree here. Knowledge is power. Action is applied power, for want of a
> better way to put it.
>
> Power is power whether applied or not. iow potential power is still power.

Knowledge needs intelligence to utilize it or else all you've got is a
Jeopardy! episode.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: John J
Date: Sep 8, 2008 06:38

Information is not knowledge and knowledge is not wisdom and wisdom is
not power. Power exists within the discourse of the masses, which have
little information and none of the virtues of knowledge or wisdom. The
mass is just one big shitpile of willful ignorance.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: Don Stockbauer
Date: Sep 8, 2008 10:58

On Sep 8, 8:38 am, John J wrote:
> Information is not knowledge and knowledge is not wisdom and wisdom is
> not power. Power exists within the discourse of the masses, which have
> little information and none of the virtues of knowledge or wisdom. The
> mass is just one big shitpile of willful ignorance.

That's right. You combine a bunch of stupid things you just get a big
stupid thing.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: student13
Date: Sep 8, 2008 22:13

very well stated !!

enjoy
cheers

On Sep 8, 6:38 pm, John J wrote:
> Information is not knowledge and knowledge is not wisdom and wisdom is
> not power. Power exists within the discourse of the masses, which have
> little information and none of the virtues of knowledge or wisdom. The
> mass is just one big shitpile of willful ignorance.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: ZerkonX
Date: Sep 9, 2008 06:14

On Mon, 08 Sep 2008 05:26:06 -0700, student13 wrote:
> But to perform any action, don't you think some knowledge is needed even
> if that knowledge turns out to be wrong knowledge? And depending on the
> result of action, we come to know that we had all the right knowledge
> needed to perform the action at that time or not?

Agree up to a point. Action is perpetual in life. With or without
Knowledge. Hearts were beating long before the knowledge of hearts.
We are talking about a human attribute to action, knowledge, which can be
a guide, as you say.

However the ability to act, right or wrong, is not action itself.
Power is kinetic. It moves. So unspent ability or knowledge is not power.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: ZerkonX
Date: Sep 9, 2008 06:32

On Mon, 08 Sep 2008 23:18:04 +1000, Sean wrote:
> Action is applied power, for want of a better way to put it.

Here's the main point of contention and very well put, I might add.
> Power is power whether applied or not. iow potential power is still
> power.

Potential is something not yet realized or applied, as you put it. Power
is realized only after being derived from potential. It is in the
discharge not in the ability to discharge.

so, "having the power" to do something is not power. The 'Having' becomes
power only after the doing.
no comments
Re: Knowledge is not Power         


Author: ZerkonX
Date: Sep 9, 2008 06:33

On Mon, 08 Sep 2008 08:38:03 -0500, John J wrote:
> The mass is just one big shitpile of willful ignorance.

Well, that's that then.
no comments
1 2 3 4 5