Re: Having Asperger's and autism
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Re: Having Asperger's and autism         


Author: John Jones
Date: Sep 15, 2008 11:48

Scott H wrote:
> I have written an essay on Asperger's Syndrome:
> http://www.geocities.com/zinites_page/asperger.html
>
>

"The disturbance causes clinically significant impairment in social,
occupational, or other important areas of functioning. "

As you may know, but not know why, I can't accept the reasoning behind
that- its logically incoherent.

How did the 'disturbance' inform you that there was an impairment??

Do you see my point? You first judge that there is a social impairment,
then you find the physical concommitments of that impairment. But then
you make an unjustified move. You THEN claim that the physical
concommitants themselves are disturbances or impairments, and that it is
these that show you that there is a social impairment!! Do you see the
circularity?
1 Comment
Re: Having Asperger's and autism         


Date: Sep 16, 2008 15:11

John Jones wrote:
> "The disturbance causes clinically significant impairment in social,
> occupational, or other important areas of functioning. "
>
> As you may know, but not know why, I can't accept the reasoning behind
> that- its logically incoherent.

That's what it says in the DSM-IV. The whole book is full of vague terms
that are open to abuse by greedy clinicians. The patient should be wary and
know that there are people out there (like me) who have sympathy for who
they are, and who they *know* they are, and not for what label they were
diagnosed with.
no comments

RELATED THREADS
SubjectArticles qty Group
Re: Asperger's kid (was/ A genetic mechanism for some types of autism?)alt.support.autism ·
Autism in Infants - Are There Signs and Symptoms of Autism to Watch For in I..alt.support.autism ·
Soft clothing for children with Autism, Aspergers, Sensory Processing Disordermisc.kids ·