GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: Hamady
Date: Aug 17, 2008 08:13

With ample evidence discovered by science, the thesis of an "infinite
universe" was tossed onto the scrap-heap of the history of scientific
ideas. Yet, more important questions were forthcoming: what existed
before the Big Bang? What force could have caused the great explosion
that resulted in a universe that did not exist before?

There is a single answer to be given to the question of what existed
before the Big Bang: God, the All-powerful and the Almighty, Who
created the earth and the heavens in great order. Many scientists, be
they believers or not, are obliged to admit this truth. Although they
may decline to admit this fact on scientific platforms, their
confessions in between the lines give them away. Renowned atheist
philosopher Anthony Flew says:

Notoriously, confession is good for the soul. I will therefore begin
by confessing that the Stratonician atheist has to be embarrassed by
the contemporary cosmological consensus. For it seems that the...
Show full article (2.80Kb)
7 Comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: Daniel T.
Date: Aug 17, 2008 08:40

Hamady gmail.com> wrote:
> what existed
> before the Big Bang? What force could have caused the great explosion
> that resulted in a universe that did not exist before?

Talking about "before the big bang" is nonsensical, because time itself
didn't exist until that moment, so there is no "before" it.
> There is a single answer to be given to the question of what existed
> before the Big Bang: God, the All-powerful and the Almighty, Who
> created the earth and the heavens in great order.

All that exists was created in the "big bang", if your god exists, it
couldn't have existed before that moment (there was no before that
moment,) and therefore your god could not have caused it.
no comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: John
Date: Aug 17, 2008 09:06

Hamady wrote:
> With ample evidence discovered by science, the thesis of an "infinite
> universe" was tossed onto the scrap-heap of the history of scientific
> ideas. [...]

It's a language issue. The concept of Infinity is safely unrealized,
privately interpreted, mathematically symbolic. What it really is cannot
matter until humankind understands why it is a necessary concept, and
that ain't gonna happen with our existing genetic makeup. We've maxed
out on it's intelligence potential.

So, until then, God is necessary to many. Living in benign insecurity is
another alternative.
no comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: Rec Room
Date: Aug 17, 2008 09:29

Hamady wrote:
>With ample evidence discovered by
> science, the thesis of an "infinite
> universe" was tossed onto the
> scrap-heap of the history of scientific
> ideas. Yet, more important questions
> were forthcoming: what existed before
> the Big Bang? What force could have
> caused the great explosion that resulted
> in a universe that did not exist before?

That's the popular characterization. Actual Big Bang theory does not
concern an explosion of matter into already existing space, but the
development of the universe over time (you're right that BBT isn't about
an *origin* of the universe, if it needed one). If the *observable
universe* was once the size of a pea, that concerns the area we observe
(13+ billion light-years in every direction around us). The rest of the
cosmos, even if more compact back then as well, could still have been
gigantic in contrast to the limited region we can only observe (today)
because the light from greater distances hasn't reached us yet.
Show full article (2.51Kb)
no comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: bigfletch8
Date: Aug 17, 2008 16:50

On Aug 18, 1:40 am, "Daniel T." earthlink.net> wrote:
> Hamady gmail.com> wrote:
>> what existed
>> before the Big Bang? What force could have caused the great explosion
>> that resulted in a universe that did not exist before?
>
> Talking about "before the big bang" is nonsensical, because time itself
> didn't exist until that moment, so there is no "before" it.
>
>> There is a single answer to be given to the question of what existed
>> before the Big Bang: God, the All-powerful and the Almighty, Who
>> created the earth and the heavens in great order.
>
> All that exists was created in the "big bang", if your god exists, it
> couldn't have existed before that moment (there was no before that
> moment,) and therefore your god could not have caused it.

I love it when you guys talk dirty <;-).....

Eternity is not about time.The mind is. The universe is 'breathing in
and out'.
Show full article (2.29Kb)
no comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: bigfletch8
Date: Aug 17, 2008 17:02

On Aug 18, 2:29 am, n...@webtv.net (Rec Room) wrote:
> Hamady wrote:
>>With ample evidence discovered by
>> science, the thesis of an "infinite
>> universe" was tossed onto the
>> scrap-heap of the history of scientific
>> ideas. Yet, more important questions
>> were forthcoming: what existed before
>> the Big Bang? What force could have
>> caused the great explosion that resulted
>> in a universe that did not exist before?
>
> That's the popular characterization. Actual Big Bang theory does not
> concern an explosion of matter into already existing space, but the
> development of the universe over time (you're right that BBT isn't about
> an *origin* of the universe, if it needed one). If the *observable
> universe* was once the size of a pea, that concerns the area we observe
> (13+ billion light-years in every direction around us). The rest of the
> cosmos, even if more compact back then as well, could still have been
> gigantic in contrast to the limited region we can only observe (today) ...
Show full article (1.95Kb)
no comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: Errol
Date: Aug 18, 2008 06:09

On Aug 17, 5:40 pm, "Daniel T." earthlink.net> wrote:
> Hamady gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Talking about "before the big bang" is nonsensical, because time itself
> didn't exist until that moment, so there is no "before" it.
>

So you "know" that our universe is not part of a multiverse then?

The many worlds interpretation of quantum theory is just rubbish then?
The four levels of multiverse are crap? (I might agree with the 4th
being rubbish anyway as I simply cannot accept information theory as a
serious basis for making cosmology predictions) Bubble theory is
bogus, string theory is strange, and m-theory is madness?

You are the scientific eqivalent of an old testament prophet.
> All that exists was created in the "big bang", if your god exists, it
> couldn't have existed before that moment (there was no before that
> moment,) and therefore your god could not have caused it.

Maybe you and the other prophets existed in a parent universe which
tunneled out of the quantum foam of a grandprophet universe
no comments
Re: GOD CREATED THE UNIVERSE FROM NOTHING         


Author: Daniel T.
Date: Aug 18, 2008 16:57

Errol gmail.com> wrote:
> "Daniel T." earthlink.net> wrote:
>> Hamady gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> Talking about "before the big bang" is nonsensical, because time itself
>> didn't exist until that moment, so there is no "before" it.
>
> So you "know" that our universe is not part of a multiverse then?

I know that a god cannot create that which he must, by definition, be
part of.

Universe is one, hence the name. It is all that is, was or ever will be.
> The many worlds interpretation of quantum theory is just rubbish then?
> The four levels of multiverse are crap?

How do you establish what is in the "universe" and what is outside it in
this case?
> You are the scientific eqivalent of an old testament prophet.

No, I just define my words a little more precisely.
Show full article (1.25Kb)
no comments