Existence is a concept of consciousness
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.philosophy only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

alt.philosophy Profile…
 Up
Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Malrassic Park
Date: Feb 10, 2008 08:46

"Existence" is a predicate made about things.
Predication is an activity of the mind.
Therefore, "Existence" is a concept of consciousness.
--
Such little questions, so many times...
103 Comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Michael Gordge
Date: Feb 10, 2008 11:55

On Feb 11, 1:46 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
> "Existence" is a predicate made about things.
> Predication is an activity of the mind.
> Therefore, "Existence" is a concept of consciousness.
> --
> Such little questions, so many times...

Nope, existence gives consciousness its identity.

Its not possible to be conscious of nothing.

Existence pre-supposes something to be conscious of and someone to be
conscious of it.

Existence can not be denied without contradiction.

Existence is identified its not created.

Ideas exist.

Ideas exist originating from sensory reality OR they exist originating
from the mind. The former is food, the latter is poison.

Examples of the former? ideas about cats dogs and trees.

Examples of the latter? god and Kant's ideas of subjectivist pro-
senseless anti-sensist mind fucking because mind originating
transcendentalizzzm.
Show full article (0.91Kb)
no comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Malrassic Park
Date: Feb 10, 2008 12:38

On Sun, 10 Feb 2008 11:55:32 -0800 (PST), Michael Gordge
xtra.co.nz> wrote:
>On Feb 11, 1:46 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
>> "Existence" is a predicate made about things.
>> Predication is an activity of the mind.
>> Therefore, "Existence" is a concept of consciousness.

Gordge states that existence, which is an axiomatic concept, gives
consciousness, another axiomatic concept, its identity, which is yet
another axiomatic concept:
>Nope, existence gives consciousness its identity.

"Morality" is a concept of consciousness. 'The concept "marriage"
cannot be formed or grasped merely by observing the behavior of a
couple: it requires the integration of their actions with a number of
concepts of consciousness, such as "contractual agreement," "morality"
and "law."' (ITOE, pp 36-37)
Show full article (1.88Kb)
8 Comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Michael Gordge
Date: Feb 10, 2008 13:28

On Feb 11, 5:38 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
> Gordge states that existence, gives consciousness, > its identity.

He said that because it is not possible to be conscious of nothing and
that to deny existence requires a contradiction.
> "Morality" is a concept of consciousness.

No its not, its a concept giving recognition of human behaviour.
> "Existence" is also a concept of consciousness:

No its not, its a concept required to give consciousness an identity.
> The distinguishing characteristic of
> logic (the art of non-contradictory identification)

Its a tool of knowledge because there are no contradictions in
reality, therefore neither can there be in the ideas theories concepts
of or about reality.

AND its a tool or art, which has fuck all use unless and until
something exists to apply the art to, e.g. to the identification of
existing entities and to identify and eliminate contradictions in
ideas theories concepts methods, which are claimed to be ideas
theories concepts methods of or about reality.

See if you can talk and explain your ideas without Kant Park.
Show full article (1.13Kb)
no comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Malrassic Park
Date: Feb 10, 2008 14:00

On Sun, 10 Feb 2008 13:28:54 -0800 (PST), Michael Gordge
xtra.co.nz> wrote:
>On Feb 11, 5:38 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Gordge states that existence, gives consciousness, > its identity.
>
>He said that because it is not possible to be conscious of nothing and
>that to deny existence requires a contradiction.

You're being an evil misquoter again. What I wrote was:

"Gordge states that existence, which is an axiomatic concept, gives
consciousness, another axiomatic concept, its identity, which is yet
another axiomatic concept."

These are all concepts of consciousness, principles of logic: "The
distinguishing characteristic of logic (the art of non-contradictory
identification) indicates the nature of the actions (actions of
consciousness required to achieve a correct identification) and their
goal (knowledge)."

Actions of CONSCIOUSNESS.
Show full article (2.53Kb)
4 Comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Michael Gordge
Date: Feb 10, 2008 14:10

On Feb 11, 7:00 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
> You're being an evil misquoter again. What I wrote was:
>
> "Gordge states that existence gives
> consciousness its identity"

I've snipped again your dishonesty, the parts which you implied I had
said.

MG
no comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Immortalist
Date: Feb 10, 2008 22:14

On Feb 10, 8:46 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
> "Existence" is a predicate made about things.
> Predication is an activity of the mind.
> Therefore, "Existence" is a concept of consciousness.
> --
> Such little questions, so many times...

Are you sure that instead of being a concept it might be an intuition,
like space and time?
no comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Immortalist
Date: Feb 10, 2008 22:16

On Feb 10, 11:55 am, Michael Gordge xtra.co.nz> wrote:
> On Feb 11, 1:46 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
>
>> "Existence" is a predicate made about things.
>> Predication is an activity of the mind.
>> Therefore, "Existence" is a concept of consciousness.
>> --
>> Such little questions, so many times...
>
> Nope, existence gives consciousness its identity.
>
> Its not possible to be conscious of nothing.
>
> Existence pre-supposes something to be conscious of and someone to be
> conscious of it.
>

I don't think existence alone can do that, you must add concepts and
abstractions, to conclude something about the sense of existence.
Show full article (1.17Kb)
4 Comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Michael Gordge
Date: Feb 11, 2008 00:26

On Feb 11, 7:00 am, Malrassic Park hotmail.com> wrote:
> Consciousness doesn't require identity, it already has one which needs
> to be protected.

What a stupid contradicting statement.

Existence is to consciousness what the first breath is to life.

Just as consciousness gets it meaning via existence, soo too does life
get its meaning via breathing.

Existence must precede consciousness, just as air to breath must
precede life.
> To protect the continuity of consciousness is to defend it against
> contradictions.

To protect consciousness is to feed it existence external of it, or
else it turns Kantian and starts eating itself.
> That does not say anything about contradictions
> existing in reality.

They dont.

Michael Gordge
no comments
Re: Existence is a concept of consciousness         


Author: Michael Gordge
Date: Feb 11, 2008 00:34

On Feb 11, 3:16 pm, Immortalist yahoo.com> wrote:
> I don't think existence alone can do that, you must add concepts and
> abstractions, to conclude something about the sense of existence.

You cant form concepts, not even of and about existence, unless and
untill there is something existing external of the mind - for the mind
to THEN become conscious of, which can ONLY happen via his senses,
eyes ears nose hands skin, SENSORY PERCEPTIONS, which then triggers
reasoning / the identification process.

Kant says man's knowledge begins with experience, which of course
requires man to ignore the simple fact that there HAS to be some thing
PRE-EXISTING to experience.

Michael Gordge
4 Comments
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9