Re: School Shootings
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.flame.psychiatry only
 
Advanced search
POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
Re: School Shootings         

Group: alt.flame.psychiatry · Group Profile
Author: barb
Date: Apr 16, 2008 18:37

Jeff L wrote:
> On Apr 16, 5:53 pm, Brittany badpsych.com> wrote:
>> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7MyuSPw5Irs
>> The United States is gaining a reputation around the world for raising
>> children who go on school shooting rampages. Earlier this year, we had
>> another one with 16-year-old Jeff Weiss, who went into his school on
>> an Indian reservation and blew away 10 friends. And guess what? He was
>> taking the antidepressant Prozac.
>>
>> Once again we see the link between antidepressants and violent
>> behavior. I was raising the alarm about this in 1999 following the
>> Columbine schools shootings. At that time we knew that those students
>> were on antidepressant drugs, but the rest of the world didn't take
>> any notice of it. The rest of the world said, "These drugs are
>> completely safe. They keep these kids happy and in a normal state so
>> they don't feel depressed." What they actually do, though, is detach
>> these kids from reality to the point they can go on shooting rampages
>> and not even have a clue that they're affecting the lives of real
>> people. It basically transforms the world into a video game that these
>> kids play out.
>>
>> It makes it very easy for them to cross that threshold and begin to
>> display violent behavior. We've seen this in the studies and finally,
>> after years and years of pounding this issue, some of it has started
>> to come out in the popular press. We're seeing a lot of warnings now
>> about antidepressant drugs and their ability to cause violent
>> behavior. We're seeing some of these drugs pulled off the market. And
>> slowly we're beginning to see the general public recognizing the link
>> between antidepressant drugs in our youth and violent behavior,
>> including school shootings.
>
> This is called "association fallacy". You are making the assumption
> that because these criminals were taking antidepressants when they
> committed violent crimes, therefore antidepressants are the reason
> they committed these crimes. For every criminal that was on
> antidepressants, however, I can point to ten who took no drugs
> whatsoever.
>
> To be frank, your theory is bullshit. There is NO evidence to support
> the claim that antidepressants cause one to be violent. None. Zero.
> Zilch.

Gangsta rap and the glorification of gats.

--
Barb
Chaplain, ARSCC (wdne)
It's Poodlin' Time!

“I think that the protections that we enjoy for freedom of worship exist
so long as we don’t step over the line. When religious worship and
belief cross over into things like fraud, victimization of others and
the disruption of the political arena, that protection is no longer
appropriate.”

--Robert Goff
Professor Emeritus, UCSC
no comments
diggit! del.icio.us! reddit!