alt.fan.heinlein
  Home FAQ Contact Sign in
alt.fan.heinlein only
 
Advanced search
December 2006
motuwethfrsasuw
    123 48
45678910 49
11121314151617 50
18192021222324 51
25262728293031 52
2006
 Jan   Feb   Mar   Apr 
 May   Jun   Jul   Aug 
 Sep   Oct   Nov   Dec 
2008 2007 2006  
total
alt.fan.heinlein Profile…
RELATED GROUPS

POPULAR GROUPS

more...

 Up
  Re: Appropriate Critical Appraisals -- previously: Re: A Final Salute To The Admiral         


Author: djinn
Date: Dec 31, 2006 18:41

Dr. Rufo wrote:
> I suggest that most of the opinions expressed were negative
> basically because the folks who posted didn't like the book and they
> generally took the time to explain their varying reasons. IMHO,
> merely saying "I didn't like it." is worthless without such
> substantiation.
>
The differing opinions on the book have been pretty interesting to me.
I thought Silver and Zakes discussion was one of the more interesting
I've seen here, not least cause they had the good sense to drop it at
the point of bursting into flames.

It is too bad that 'criticize' has come to mean 'denigrate' rather than
' evaluate'. It's probably inevitable in media where the final result
comes down to 'I liked it' or 'I didn't like it'.
Show full article (1.22Kb)
1 Comment
  Re: Happy New Year!!         


Author: Sean
Date: Dec 31, 2006 18:18

"Dave Adalian" sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
news:bMZlh.1503$ji1.105@newssvr12.news.prodigy.net...
> "Dr. Rufo" mindspring.com> wrote in message
> news:bDYlh.5936$yx6.989@newsread2.news.pas.earthlink.net...
>>
>>
>> Sean wrote:
>>> "TreetopAngel" bresnan.net> wrote in message
>>> news:Gc2dncufdN1fSgrYnZ2dnUVZ_qmpnZ2d@bresnan.com...
>>>
>>>>Wishing everyone a Happy New Year!
>>>>
>>>>Hugs,
>>>>E!
>>>>(off duty in the bar tonight)
>>>
>>>
>>> Got any good hangover cures?
>>>
>>> (The morning after here in Oz) ...
Show full article (1.41Kb)
no comments
  Re: Happy New Year!!         


Author: Dave Adalian
Date: Dec 31, 2006 17:48

"Dr. Rufo" mindspring.com> wrote in message
news:bDYlh.5936$yx6.989@newsread2.news.pas.earthlink.net...
>
>
> Sean wrote:
>> "TreetopAngel" bresnan.net> wrote in message
>> news:Gc2dncufdN1fSgrYnZ2dnUVZ_qmpnZ2d@bresnan.com...
>>
>>>Wishing everyone a Happy New Year!
>>>
>>>Hugs,
>>>E!
>>>(off duty in the bar tonight)
>>
>>
>> Got any good hangover cures?
>>
>> (The morning after here in Oz)
>>
>> hrrmm...... ...
Show full article (1.01Kb)
no comments
  Re: Happy New Year!!         


Author: Sean
Date: Dec 31, 2006 17:43

"TreetopAngel" bresnan.net> wrote in message
news:hKydndLVsMOgyAXYnZ2dnUVZ_vGinZ2d@bresnan.com...
> "Sean" cringes:
>
>> "TreetopAngel" bresnan.net> wrote in message
>> news:Gc2dncufdN1fSgrYnZ2dnUVZ_qmpnZ2d@bresnan.com...
>>> Wishing everyone a Happy New Year!
>>>
>>> Hugs,
>>> E!
>>> (off duty in the bar tonight)
>>
>> Got any good hangover cures?
>>
>> (The morning after here in Oz)
>>
>> hrrmm......
>
> Heh Heh!!!
> ...
Show full article (0.97Kb)
1 Comment
  Re: Why I loathed _Variable Star_         


Author: Mike Van Pelt
Date: Dec 31, 2006 15:52

In article <6cGdnXwFQrtavwvYnZ2dnUVZ_tSunZ2d@forethought.net>,
Vance P. Frickey ricochet.com> wrote:
>[...] I flushed my Republican Party voter registration card
>during Bush I's administration (when he sold us out over the
>"assault weapons ban") and rejoined my party of first
>allegiance, the Libertarians.
...
>The lack of resolve and courage when confronted with violent
>external threats from both Communism and Islam is eerily
>similar. Take press clippings from the Vietnam era and
>today, paint Liquid Paper over the names of Ho Chi Minh and
>Osama bin Laden, and the age of the paper on which the
>clippings are printed is the only clue of when the articles
>were written.
>
>The evidence is persuasive that we were unfair in labeling
>John Kerry and Ted Kennedy Communist sympathizers back
>during the Cold War. The truth is more sinister - the
>driving force behind their political careers - and those of
>a number of right-wing politicos - seems to be a certain ...
Show full article (2.20Kb)
no comments
  Re: Happy New Year!!         


Author: Dave Adalian
Date: Dec 31, 2006 15:45

"TreetopAngel" bresnan.net> wrote in message
news:fo2dnUxAKp2q1wXYnZ2dnUVZ_hmtnZ2d@bresnan.com...
> "Dave Adalian" asks:
>
>> "TreetopAngel" bresnan.net> wrote in message
>> news:Gc2dncufdN1fSgrYnZ2dnUVZ_qmpnZ2d@bresnan.com...
>>> Wishing everyone a Happy New Year!
>>>
>>> Hugs,
>>> E!
>>> (off duty in the bar tonight)
>>>
>>> --
>>> "Today I live in the quiet, joyous expectation of good." ~~Ernest Holmen
>>
>> The happiest of new years to all of you. Very nice Holmen quote, E!. Who
>> is he?
>>
> LOL! I knew I should have looked him up, someone was sure to ask.
> Frankly, I have no idea, I saw the quote on an office door at the hospital ...
Show full article (1.23Kb)
1 Comment
  Re: Why I loathed _Variable Star_         


Author: Dave Adalian
Date: Dec 31, 2006 15:44

"Chris Zakes" gmail.com> wrote in message
news:d8dgp2pq02um68mdeo49cec7pi7t9s8c3d@4ax.com...
> On Sun, 31 Dec 2006 19:23:11 GMT, an orbital mind-control laser
> caused Spider Robinson to write:
>
>
> Uh huh... and what portion of the Geneva Convention allows hijacking
> of civilian aircraft to attack civilian targets? Last time I checked,
> the Geneva Convention applied to nation-states at war, not "WHACKOS,
> crackpot individuals" or "a fringe group of nuts". For that matter,
> since when does the *United States* Constitution apply in places like
> Afghanistan or Iraq?
>
> -Chris Zakes
> Texas
>
Show full article (1.45Kb)
no comments
  Re: A Final Salute To The Admiral         


Author: Chris Zakes
Date: Dec 31, 2006 14:20

On Sun, 31 Dec 2006 18:15:58 GMT, an orbital mind-control laser
caused Spider Robinson to write:
>Brethren and sistren,
>
>It has been exactly 40 years since Robert A. Heinlein last won a Hugo Award,
>for his novel THE MOON IS A HARSH MISTRESS. He still holds the all-time
>record for most Best-Novel Hugos (4).
>
>But isn¹t 5 a nice round number? And wouldn¹t he have loved becoming the
>first man ever to win Best Novel POSTHUMOUSLY, 29 years after his death?
>For a yarn he dreamed up over 50 years ago?

Sounds like a plan to me. Let's everybody vote for "For Us the Living"
for this year's Hugo award.

-Chris Zakes
Texas

Dragons don't have friends. The nearest they can get to the idea is an enemy who
is still alive.

-Terry Pratchett, "Guards! Guards!"
no comments
  Re: Why I loathed _Variable Star_         


Author: Spider Robinson
Date: Dec 31, 2006 11:23

Since I'm here I thought I would briefly address Puppet_Sock's original
complaints--at least as they have been reproduced in still-extant messages;
his original has vanished from my server.

Why would I care more about Parliament Hill or the CN Tower, P_S? I have
never so much as visited either in my life. I am an American, born and
raised IN NEW YORK CITY, now living in British Columbia. My daughter was a
New Yorker at the time of 9/11 and still is. Glancing at my website or
author bio would have told you these things. Other people's ignorance is
easier to handle than one's own...to paraphrase your own insult.
Show full article (6.63Kb)
no comments
  Re: A Final Salute To The Admiral         


Author: bajasteve
Date: Dec 31, 2006 11:21

Spider Robinson wrote:
> Brethren and sistren,
>
> It has been exactly 40 years since Robert A. Heinlein last won a Hugo Award,
> for his novel THE MOON IS A HARSH MISTRESS. He still holds the all-time
> record for most Best-Novel Hugos (4).
>
> But isn¹t 5 a nice round number? And wouldn¹t he have loved becoming the
> first man ever to win Best Novel POSTHUMOUSLY, 29 years after his death?
> For a yarn he dreamed up over 50 years ago?
>
> As for me, it¹s been 23 years since I won my own third Hugo Award (2 of them
> shared). I¹ve never won for Best Novel, only for Novellas and Short Story.
>
> I ask you to consider our novel VARIABLE STAR this year. The Hugo Award,
> SF¹s highest honour, is one of very few arts awards voted by the customers:
> anyone can vote.
>
> Until June 30, it costs only US$50 or £28 to nominate and vote for the Hugo,
> by becoming a Supporting Member of the World Science Fiction Convention ...
Show full article (1.68Kb)
2 Comments
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9