... of enthusiasm. A less extreme retributivist would defend fewer conditions. Our...Proposition 4 brings the utilitarian-retributivist conflict into sharp focus. The...enough to provide deterrence. The retributivists have another answer, which goes...good yardstick. Consider murder. One retributivist answer is that equalization entails...and we disagree with the retributivist on how the amount of...

...of enthusiasm. A less extreme retributivist would defend fewer conditions. Our...Proposition 4 brings the utilitarian-retributivist conflict into sharp focus. The...enough to provide deterrence. The retributivists have another answer, which goes...good yardstick. Consider murder. One retributivist answer is that equalization entails...summary we disagree with the retributivists that the state must punish...