knucmo wrote: Kant - whyknucmo and i reallyagree (but argue because he ...) then (SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ~(SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ---- ~(KantsProgrammeSuccessful) You, Knucmo, have claimed this syllogism invalid. ....htm http://www.nutters.org/docs/kant-sap -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- galathaea: prankster, fablist, magician, liar...
Kant - whyknucmo and i reallyagree (but argue because he is... resting upon no empirical grounds. " Kant was monovalent. He was an ...) then (SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ~(SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ---- ~(KantsProgrammeSuccessful) You, Knucmo, have claimed this syllogism invalid....not contingent, nor analytic. SYNTHETIC. Hence, Kant anticipates the development of Non-...
Kant - whyknucmo and i reallyagree (but argue because he is... resting upon no empirical grounds. " Kant was monovalent. He was an ...) then (SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ~(SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ---- ~(KantsProgrammeSuccessful) You, Knucmo, have claimed this syllogism invalid....not contingent, nor analytic. SYNTHETIC. Hence, Kant anticipates the development of Non-...
... title states, "whyknucmo and i reallyagree (but argue because...then (SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ~(SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ---- ~(KantsProgrammeSuccessful) You, Knucmo, have claimed this syllogism invalid...Despite logic being advanced since Kant's day, I don't...the intuition, and one that Kant himself denies. <snip> But the...
...George Dance wrote: Exactly. That's Kant's point. No, it is not....principle of contradiction. We're discussing Kant's own example here. That IS Kant's example from the Critique. He was arguing against those who thought mathematics was..., what I have offered of Kant's is still true: The discernment... least one other synthetic proposition - Kant's invoking it here simply ...
On Feb 6, 3:34 pm, "knucmo" <stevejoua...@hotmail.com> wrote: In other words, Kant's doctrine holds that ... unknowable and that he is contradicting himself. But Kant draws a distinction between negative knowledge, and positive knowledge of content. Kant claims we cannot have the latter about ... cannot be given in these categories i agree with the slant of the argument as ...
... spring from Understanding and Reason Kant terms "synthetic a priori." And...apodictic certainty in judgments. OTC;Kant is saying that 'pure Understanding...yet he attacks the rationalists. Why? He cannot refute Hume's...which is the wrong method. Kantagreed with Hume that the...an argument, not any conclusion. Agreed. (Crosses fingers before pressing the...
... spring from Understanding and Reason Kant terms "synthetic a priori." And ... apodictic certainty in judgments. OTC; Kant is saying that 'pure Understanding ... yet he attacks the rationalists. Why? He cannot refute Hume's ... You're confusing 'rationalism' with (Kant's definition of) 'analytic'. Obviously,...which is the wrong method. Kantagreed with Hume that the...
...one with your comments on Kant's ideas.] Oh, really? I thought the anger in my response was ...' dictated by the Ayn Rand Institute. Why do you think I'm going ... did you acquire your hatred toward Kant, if not from some Randian source?... answer: But I don't hate Kant. It certainly doesn't answer my ...giving, or supporting, my views of Kant. If you've failed to understand ...
...) then (SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ~(SomePhenomenologicalStatement) ---- ~(KantsProgrammeSuccessful) You, Knucmo, have claimed this syllogism invalid. You.... But you do not answer why the quotes I have given ...'s totally and utterly off as far as Kant's position goes really. It should be: ... not an affirmation. In fact, Kant even argues in the Analytic, that ...
