...placed into the box then the space inside the box has been removed by the same volume, your contention...along has been, the volume of space remained identical whether there were pebbles...agree with. This thread is about *removing space* e.g. this time by...box completely. According to you, the space remains the same even when ..., so why does not the space remain when its squashed? Whats ...

... Kant wants to imagine can be removed from the reality of objects which..., therefore they can not be removed in reality without also the ..., then they must correspond to reality. You remove density with the ... of matter. You remove colour with the removal of matter. You ... matter. You remove space with the removal of matter. And NOT even imagination can remove them without matter and call that...

...reanimater_2...@yahoo.com> wrote: If we remove from our empirical concept of ... moment and it would be removed from your empirical concept. I ... placing them somewhere else in space. Hint: You can destroy a ....html Not being able to "remove space" is not what makes space different or unique to anything else,... dust ashes to ashes space to space, it all stays. Time ...

...Immortalist <reanimater_2...@yahoo.com> wrote: If we remove from our empirical concept of a body...re just placing them somewhere else in space. Hint: You can destroy a car Mortal... from, you can only change its form. Not being able to "remove space" is not what makes space different or unique to anything else, try ...Dust to dust ashes to ashes space to space, it all stays. Time is not...

... is filled with pebbles, does space flow out of the pail...s right. Good analogy. Does space flow to 'occupy' the 'non...the pebbles were, is it? Space is something, its not nothing...Nothing means nothing, not even space, the answer therefore is, check...meaning to the concept of space in the absence of any...as you claim, pebbles displace space in a pail, it is...

... is filled with pebbles, does space flow out of the pail?...'s right. Good analogy. Does space flow to 'occupy' the 'non-... the pebbles were, is it? Space is something, its not nothing.... Nothing means nothing, not even space, the answer therefore is, check ... meaning to the concept of space in the absence of any ...as you claim, pebbles displace space in a pail, it is...

...pail is filled with pebbles, does space flow out of the pail? ...'s right. Good analogy. Does space flow to 'occupy' the 'non-... the pebbles were, is it? Space is something, its not nothing. ... Nothing means nothing, not even space, the answer therefore is, check ... meaning to the concept of space in the absence of any ... as you claim, pebbles displace space in a pail, it is ...

.... I don't know if space existed before the Universe began. ...is wrong" Ayn Rand You said, space is where objects exist, the corollary... that statement being, there was space before the universe, you also said that space was a part of the universe, so which ... It cant be both. But "space is where objects exist" does not imply "there was space before the universe". It is perfectly ...

... such as your No.4 4. I don't know if space existed before the Universe began. Check your premises. "There are no ... check your premises because one of them is wrong" Ayn Rand You said, space is where objects exist, the corollary of that statement being, there was space before the universe, you also said that space was a part of the universe, so which is it? It cant be both. ...

... pail is filled with pebbles, does space flow out of the pail? ...'s right. Good analogy. Does space flow to 'occupy' the 'non-... the pebbles were, is it? Space is something, its not nothing.... Nothing means nothing, not even space, the answer therefore is, check ... meaning to the concept of space in the absence of any ... conception of the nature of space is too too solid. You'...