... and will decide whether they'll lift the wild-animal consumption warning issued in January, said spokesman Tom Slater. Roger DeGroat, a New Jersey squirrel hunter, says he may be a little more hesitant about eating squirrel because of the mixed ...'t taste like chicken. "I can't say it tastes like chicken. I can't say it tastes like turkey," DeGroat said. "It tastes a lot like squirrel."