...: allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. I say it shouldn't. I just saw Dark Knight, and like many modern films it suffered terribly both from a relentlessly depressing tone, and serverely underlit scenes. We are not dogs: we don't see everything ...

... L. wrote: ToolPackinMama wrote: Steven L. wrote: allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. Inevitably the characters will be more dimensional, more flawed, more ambiguous. They always were. It ...

...: allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. I say it shouldn't.  I just saw Dark Knight, and like many modern films it suffered terribly both from a relentlessly depressing tone, and serverely underlit scenes. We are not dogs:  we don't see everything ...

ToolPackinMama wrote: Steven L. wrote: allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. Inevitably the characters will be more dimensional, more flawed, more ambiguous. They always were. It ain't broke ...

...There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. I'm of the opinion... should. In all honesty the hopeful Utopian Trek future doesn't look so plausible in today... thing that everybody else is doing? Star Trek wasn't like any other show, why should a Trek movie fall prey to the same follies of ...

Steven L. wrote: allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. Inevitably the characters will be more dimensional, more flawed, more ambiguous. They always were. It ain't broke don't fix it.

... There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. I'm of the opinion... should. In all honesty the hopeful Utopian Trek future doesn't look so plausible in today...damn thing that everybody else is doing? Star Trek wasn't like any other show, why should a Trek movie fall prey to the same follies of other...

allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. I say it shouldn't. I just saw Dark Knight, and like many modern films it suffered terribly both from a relentlessly depressing tone, and serverely underlit scenes. We are not dogs: we don't see everything in black...

... Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. I'm of the opinion ... it should. In all honesty the hopeful Utopian Trek future doesn't look so plausible in today'... shouting, "Shut up already, humans!" So yes, the new trek movie should be "darker" in tone than most of the other trek movies. It should be more like TOS. GeneK...

allemannster wrote: There's a poll on Trekmovie.com about whether the new Trek should be darker in tone than the other movies. Inevitably the characters will be more dimensional, more flawed, more ambiguous. J.J. Abrams likes it that way. He's not the eternal optimist about Man's future that Roddenberry was. And Roddenberry didn't like ...